Skip to content

Lesson 11 · September 11, 1982

The Christian and the State

September 5-11.

"Then saith he unto them, Render therefore unto Caesar the things which are Caesar's; and unto God the things that are God's" (Matt. 22:21).

From the very moment Christianity came into existence, it has been confronted with the question: How should the followers of Christ relate to the state and its various functions and to the civil authorities who are in charge? Each generation of believers must come to grips with this question in its own ways. And in each nation where the church has been planted or where the gospel of the kingdom is being proclaimed, Christians must find their own forms of relating to the state and to the civil authorities. The relationship between the church and the state cannot—and should not!—take the same form everywhere. What seemed an appropriate way of relating to the state at one time may no longer be suitable—or even possible—at another. Though the varying circumstances in the world may demand different forms of relating to the state, these forms must be solidly based on sound biblical principles.

For our understanding of these biblical principles it is imperative that we know of the circumstances in which the early Christians lived. Christianity arose at a time when the state was at the same time a religious community. Although there was tolerance for other religions, deference to the emperor was required on religious grounds. The rise of a new religion such as Christianity was viewed as a direct threat against the state. The early Christian church was a noninstitutional church without property, power, or privileges—without schools, hospitals, or elaborate organization. It was a lay movement. A relationship between church and state as we know it now—namely, a relationship between two different spheres of interest or power or organization—actually did not exist. It was a relationship between the believers and the laws, institutions, customs, and authorities of the state in which they lived.

The early Christians' attitude toward country, customs, culture, and civil authorities was strongly influenced by their belief that the form of this world was passing and that soon Christ would return to establish His own kingdom of righteousness.

Part 1 — Sunday, September 5

Submission

What is to be the Christian's attitude toward civil government?

"Let every soul be subject unto the higher powers. For there is no power but of God: the powers that be are ordained of God. Whosoever therefore resisteth the power, resisteth the ordinance of God" (Rom. 13:1, 2).

No society can exist without some type of government and form of social control. For that reason every society has some form of government for the good of its members. The more complex these societies become, the more elaborate and pervasive also the system of government has to become. It seeks to maintain order, to smooth relationships, to settle disputes between people, to guarantee the functioning of institutions necessary for existence, to protect life, property, individual freedoms, and to promote the general welfare of society as a whole. For these reasons all people must obey civil authority and submit themselves to its law, orders, and regulations. However, Christians go beyond that. Their attitude toward civil authority is not merely based on human logic and expediency; they submit to earthly rulers as unto the Lord. Revolt against government is rebellion against God, who has instituted it and ordained it for the well-being of all. And rendering things unto Caesar that by divine ordinance belong to Caesar is religious duty and an expression of giving glory to God.

What are some of the functions of government the Bible mentions specifically? Rom. 13:3, 7; 1 Peter 2:12-14.

Ideally, and in the divine plan for it, government exists for the good of its citizens. It accomplishes that in at least two ways: (1) by developing, encouraging, and stimulating organizations and institutions that really contribute to the well-being of all; (2) by restraining, suppressing, and even removing those orders and organizations that have an evil influence on society or create divisions and disorder.

Should Christians actively participate in these two functions of government? Give examples from Scripture to support your view.

Some believers are of the opinion that members of the church should not be involved in government. They point to the danger of becoming contaminated by corruption and of being held responsible for all actions. Others are of the opinion, however, that by involvement in government, Christians can influence society for good and contribute to the advance of the kingdom of God.

Further Study: The Desire of Ages, pp. 601-603.

Part 2 — Monday, September 6

Dual Citizenship

"Our commonwealth is in heaven, and from it we await a Savior, the Lord Jesus Christ" (Phil. 3:20, RSV).

Christians hold a dual citizenship—one in the kingdom of God, and the other in the nation in which they reside. But what does that mean? Some have seen in this dual citizenship an inherent conflict. Since God's kingdom is not of this world, they say, Christians can not actually live as citizens of both. (See John 18:36.) They must choose between one or the other. Many other believers think, however, that the kingdom of God is not a place or a country outside of this present world. It rather is a sphere, an attitude, a life-style which permeates the whole life and thought and gives citizenship here its special meaning. They say the kingdom of God is within them. (See Luke 17:21.) What do you think?

What are the meanings of the biblical term "kingdom of God" Mark 1:14, 15; Luke 10:8-11; 18:15-17.

Contrary to most people's thinking in the time of Christ, the kingdom Jesus proclaimed was not a territory with visible structures or institutions of power. Rather, the kingdom of God consists of the lordship of Christ in our lives, which is realized in our redemption and expressed in worship and in our obedience of His law. In this sense the kingdom of God is a reality on earth. This kingdom is not a new social order established apart from earthly societies and governments. It rather works in and through these earthly institutions. Christians, as citizens of the kingdom of God, are called to live out these principles of that kingdom within their citizenship on earth. Our citizenship in heaven, therefore, does not change our earthly citizenship. Rather, our citizenship on earth receives new meaning and direction as a result of our citizenship in heaven.

When will these two citizenships become one? Matt. 25:31, 34; Rev. 7:9-12.

With the coming of Jesus into this world, the kingdom of God has been established. And all who receive Him and accept Him as Lord and Saviour are citizens of that kingdom of God. At the same time, however, the full reign of Christ has not yet been established on this earth. Many people have never even heard of Him. And many others continue to reject Christ as Lord of their lives. At the second coming of Christ the kingdom will be initiated. It will be fully established at the close of the 1000 years.

Further Study: The Desire of Ages, pp. 547-551.

Part 3 — Tuesday, September 7

God and Caesar

"He said unto them, Render therefore unto Caesar the things which be Caesar's and unto God the things which be God's" (Luke 20:25).

God removes kings and sets up kings (Dan. 2:21). All things belong to Him, the earth and its fullness. All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to Christ (Matt. 28:18). There is no power without Him. Whether thrones or dominions or principalities or authorities—all things were created through Him and for Him (Col. 1:16). This testimony of Scripture should prevent us from a completely dualistic understanding of Jesus' words recorded in Mark 12:17, Luke 20:25, and Matthew 22:21. The things which belong to Caesar and the things which belong to God are not two entirely separate entities, domains, or spheres of influence. God is in ultimate control of everything. Our whole life belongs to Him—the government is instituted by God, and the authorities are ministers of God, attending to His interests (Rom. 13:1-7).

Although separating the things which belong to Caesar from the things which belong to God, Jesus also emphasized the fact that in His kingdom the earthly and the heavenly belong together, under God. From this viewpoint—since the things belonging to Caesar actually belong to God—the government is a steward! Citizens of the kingdom of God pay taxes, tribute, revenues, and respect to earthly rulers, as unto God. Authorities are the servants of God.

What attitude should Christians take, though, when civil authorities make requirements that conflict with God's requirements? Acts 5:29.

Sin has permeated every aspect of life on earth, every institution, every structure. Government, though ordained by God, is no exception. It also is run by imperfect human beings and, like everything else, constantly influenced by powers of evil. Under these conditions it is unavoidable that at times governments issue rules and regulations or establish structures and organizations which are contrary to the principles of the kingdom of God. In such cases the followers of Christ should obey God rather than men.

Can you think of some examples of legislation or of institutions which are in flagrant conflict with the Word of God and the principles of His kingdom? Could Christians ever participate in acts of opposition to the government?

Further Study: Testimonies, vol. 1, pp. 201-204.

Part 4 — Wednesday, September 8

Church and State

"Submit yourselves to every ordinance of man for the Lord's sake: whether it be to the king, as supreme; or unto governors, as unto them that are sent by him for the punishment of evildoers, and for the praise of them that do well" (1 Peter 2:13, 14).

At this point the question must be raised: How do the counsels given by Christ regarding the Christian's attitude toward civil ordinances and authority apply to the church as an institution in its relationship to the state? It is important that we notice a distinction first. The New Testament Christian does not know about church-state relationships that developed after the death of the apostles. The counsels are addressed to the followers of Christ in their individual relationship to government, legal ordinances, and social institutions. The emphasis thereby is on good conduct, submission, and the right attitude—never upon rights or privileges. But with the spread of the gospel and the christianization of many countries in the world, the church itself underwent some powerful changes. It began to acquire properties and to develop institutions of its own. It developed structures and organization with its own government and entered into business, often big business. As a result, new forms of relationship developed between the church and the state. These have given rise to great conflicts and powerful confrontations because that relationship is no longer one between individual believers and civil authorities, but between two institutions of considerable influence.

What principles should guide the church as an institution in its relationship to the state? Titus 3:1; Matt. 22:21.

In church-state relations we are confronted with areas of interest that may belong to both the church and the state—the education of children, for instance. As a social institution, the church must submit to the secular ordinances and laws which govern such institutions in the land. It may thank God if the state allows the church some special privileges (tax exemption, for instance), but the church should submit when the state exercises its legitimate authority over these institutional aspects of the church. Only when the state intrudes in what specifically belongs to the church such as the formulation and teaching of doctrines, the ordination of its ministers, or the believers' relationship to God, the church may rightly protest. It is to meet such issues that the church has long maintained a Department of Public Affairs and Religious Liberty. Representation is also maintained at the United Nations and various national government centers.

Why is separation of church and state the best policy with regard to potential conflicts between the two? What does separation of church and state really mean?

Part 5 — Thursday, September 9

Peace

"I exhort therefore, that, first of all, supplications, prayers, intercessions, and giving of thanks, be made for all men; for kings, and for all that are in authority; that we may lead a quiet and peaceable life in all godliness and honesty. For this is good and acceptable in the sight of God our Saviour" (1 Tim. 2:1-3).

Christians are peacemakers. (See Matt. 5:9.) One way to make peace is through intercessory prayers for those who are in authority. Another is to live peaceably with all men (Rom. 12:18) and to work actively toward peace as a sign of the kingdom of God. (See Luke 10:5, 6.) This peace is not just an absence of war, though that is part of it. The peace Christians are urged to seek and to pursue for all men (Ps. 34:14) is the peace given to us by our Lord Jesus Christ, the Prince of Peace (John 14:27). This peace should be established within the church itself and also pursued in the world.

What attitude should prevail therefore among believers when conflicts do arise? Col. 3:15; 1 Cor. 6:1-8; Phil. 2:1-5.

Though Christians do have a very positive attitude toward government, they nevertheless are urged not to seek arbitration outside of their communion of faith. A number of reasons are given. First, believers ought to be an example to the world—examples of peace, fellowship, and love. If society cannot see these exemplified in the church, then where would they find such a model? Second, government agencies are definitely of a lower order than the church. The apostle speaks of the "unrighteous" (1 Cor. 6:1, RSV), "unjust" (KJV), and of those who are "least esteemed by the church" (6:4). Third, it puts the whole church to shame if we cannot find persons wise enough in the church to decide between members who have conflicts with each other (6:5, 6). It actually is a defeat for the gospel. Finally, Christians have to learn to have the mind of Christ, in humility counting others better than themselves, having other people's interest in mind, suffering wrong and being defrauded rather than to be wrong themselves (6:7-9). The church ought to set an example to the government and to society as a whole, rather than turn to them for justice.

In what ways can Christians best promote peace? Rom 12:16-20; 1 Peter 3:8-10.

We ought to realize that a separation of church and state does not mean a separation of religion from life. Who would be able to pursue peace better than the followers of Christ?

Further Study: Prophets and Kings, pp. 191, 192.

Part 6 — Friday, September 10

Respect and Caution

"He said unto them, the kings of the Gentiles exercise lordship over them; and they that exercise authority upon them are called benefactors. But ye shall not be so: but he that is greatest among you, let him be as the younger; and he that is chief, as he that doth serve" (Luke 22:25, 26).

Earthly governments are not an acceptable model for church organization. In the first place, earthly governments are built on power, whether by contract or by absorption. Second, the Christian concept of leadership is centered in Jesus Christ, whose kingdom is not of this earth. His leadership was characterized by voluntary submission, humility, and service (servanthood).

What was Jesus' reaction to the report that an evil king would kill Him? Luke 13:31, 32.

The Bible portrays both respect and caution in its attitude toward government. On the one hand, we are urged to subject ourselves to its authority because it has been instituted by God and to pray for the earthly rulers. On the other hand, the Bible also speaks of those earthly rulers as "unrighteous" (1 Cor. 6:1, RSV), as "least esteemed by the church" (1 Cor. 6:4, RSV), as outright evil, and as persecutors of the righteous (Revelation 13 through 18). The book of Revelation portrays symbols of many such evil rulers. Jesus Himself called King Herod, who was head of the Jewish government at His time, "that fox" (Luke 13:31, 32). In fact, Jesus told the Pharisees to "go and tell that fox" that He would continue with His work until He had finished it. That sounds like a revolutionary attitude. However, Jesus was not a revolutionary! He kept a balance between the demands of the kingdom of God and the ordinances of this world. He rebuked evildoers and criticized evil practices; yet He submitted Himself voluntarily to them.

How can the church become more active in promoting peace and prosperity in the nation and in the world?

"In conformity to the divine requirements there is a transforming power that brings peace and good will among men. If the teachings of God's word were made the controlling influence in the life of every man and woman, if mind and heart were brought under its restraining power, the evils that now exist in national and in social life would find no place."—Prophets and Kings, p. 192.

Further Study: The Acts of the Apostles, pp. 68, 69.

Bible texts in this lesson

Matthew 22:21 · Romans 13:1 · Romans 13:2 · Romans 13:3 · Romans 13:7 · 1 Peter 2:12-14 · Philippians 3:20 · John 18:36 · Luke 17:21 · Mark 1:14 · Mark 1:15 · Luke 10:8-11 · Luke 18:15-17 · Matthew 25:31 · Matthew 25:34 · Revelation 7:9-12 · Luke 20:25 · Daniel 2:21 · Matthew 28:18 · Colossians 1:16 · Mark 12:17 · Romans 13:1-7 · Acts 5:29 · 1 Peter 2:13 · 1 Peter 2:14 · Titus 3:1 · 1 Timothy 2:1-3 · Matthew 5:9 · Romans 12:18 · Luke 10:5 · Luke 10:6 · Psalms 34:14 · John 14:27 · Colossians 3:15 · 1 Corinthians 6:1-8 · Philippians 2:1-5 · 1 Corinthians 6:1 · Romans 12:16-20 · 1 Peter 3:8-10 · Luke 22:25 · Luke 22:26 · Luke 13:31 · Luke 13:32 · 1 Corinthians 6:4 · Revelation 13

My notes

Saved in this browser. Sign in to see your notes on other devices.

Download lesson PDF Download quarter PDF · 13 lessons