Skip to content

Lesson 3 · January 19, 1991

God's Rule or Human Rule?

January 13-19.

This Week's Study: 1 Samuel 7:15-8:22.

Memory Text: "And the Lord said unto Samuel, Hearken unto the voice of the people in all that they say unto thee: for they have not rejected thee, but they have rejected me, that I should not reign over them" (1 Samuel 8:7).

Ignoring Divine Guidance Has Tragic Consequences. When God's people ignore His counsel and insist on having their own way, the Lord sometimes acknowledges their choice, obliging them to live with the consequences.

Outline

I. Samuel's Ministry; Schools of the Prophets (1 Sam. 7:15-17).

II. "We Want a King" (1 Sam. 8:1-9).

III. Dangers of a Monarchy (1 Sam. 8:9-22).

Prophets Speak for God. From earliest Bible times God chose men and women to speak for Him. Abraham was called a prophet. (See Gen. 20:7.) Moses enjoyed a relationship with God that went beyond that of prophets in general. (See Num. 12:6-8.) Samuel's ministry marked a new era. He was the first to establish the prophetic office. As founder and president of the schools of the prophets, he trained young men to assist him in his teaching ministry and in shepherding his people Israel.

What a disappointment to him, then, to find the people dissatisfied with the system of prophet-judge under the kingship of God! They clamored for a king, so that they might be "like the other nations." Samuel knew that the entire future history of Israel was at stake in this decision.

God treats His children as intelligent, rational creatures. He warns them of dangers and appeals for them to accept His plans, but then He allows them freedom of choice. This understanding of God's dealing with humans is well illustrated in today's lesson.

I. Samuel's Ministry; Schools of the Prophets (1 Sam. 7:15-17)

1. What three major offices did Samuel hold as leader of God's people? 1 Sam. 3:20; 7:9, 15-17.

Samuel's work and ministry marked a transition period in Israel's history. He was the last of the judges, and the first of the official prophets. He also served as a Levitical priest in the absence of the sanctuary services, which had been discontinued with the destruction of the tabernacle at Shiloh. God used Samuel to set up a new form of government at this perilous time in Israel's history.

2. What other important work occupied Samuel's energies? 1 Sam. 19:20.

Samuel was the founder and president of the schools of the prophets. (See Patriarchs and Prophets, pp. 593, 663.) He gathered companies of dedicated young men, known as "sons of the prophets," to these schools to train them as leaders and teachers of the oracles of God. The term Naioth in Ramah (1 Sam. 19:18, 19) refers to "a place 'in Ramah,' where Samuel and the 'sons of the prophets' dwelt, and where David stayed for some time while hiding from Saul (1 Sa 19:18, 19, 22, 23; 20:1). Some have suggested that the Hebrew term may mean 'dwelling,' in the sense of a 'dormitory' in which prophets lived."—SDA Bible Dictionary, revised edition, p. 776.

The schools of the prophets were located at Ramah and Kirjath-jearim. Later under the ministry of Elijah and Elisha there were others at Jericho, Bethel, and Gilgal.

"The 'sons of the prophets' were not necessarily direct recipients of the prophetic gift, but were divinely called, as are gospel ministers today, to instruct the people in the will and ways of God. The schools of the prophets were a powerful force to restrain the tide of evil that often threatened to submerge the Hebrew people in a flood of idolatry, materialism, and injustice, and provided a barrier against the fast-spreading wave of corruption."—SDA Bible Dictionary, revised edition, p. 903.

3. Study the following facts about the schools of the prophets as outlined by Ellen White, and supported by other Bible scholars. (See Patriarchs and Prophets, pp. 592-602.) Do you see any parallels to the pattern God has given His modern-day church for education?

Purpose of the schools: ______

a. To supplement the educational process provided by the home and parents, especially for those who desired to search deeper into spiritual truth.

b. To serve as a barrier against widespread corruption.

c. To provide for the moral and spiritual welfare of youth.

d. To promote the future prosperity of the nation by "furnishing it with men qualified to act in the fear of God."—Patriarchs and Prophets, p. 593.

Course of Study:

a. The law of God as given through Moses.

b. Sacred history.

c. Sacred music and poetry.

d. Practical training in the vocations such as tilling the soil and mechanical skills.

e. The cultivation of personal piety and devotion.

Learning was experiential, not merely academic. "A spirit of devotion was cherished. Not only were students taught the duty of prayer, but they were taught how to pray, how to approach their Creator, how to exercise faith in Him, and how to understand and obey the teachings of His Spirit. Sanctified intellects brought forth from the treasure house of God things new and old, and the Spirit of God was manifested in prophecy and sacred song."—Patriarchs and Prophets, p. 594.

What major differences do you see between the kind of education given in the schools of the prophets and that usually given in schools and colleges today? Where are your children being trained? Why is Christian education so important?

II. "We Want a King" (1 Sam. 8:1-9)

4. What specific circumstances prompted the elders in Israel to ask Samuel to give them a king? 1 Sam. 8:1-5.

"It was with the full assent of the nation that Samuel had appointed his sons to office; but they did not prove themselves worthy of their father's choice. . . . The sons of the prophet had not heeded the precepts which he had sought to impress upon their minds. . . . The warning given to Eli had not exerted the influence upon the mind of Samuel that it should have done. He had been to some extent too indulgent with his sons, and the result was apparent in their character and life. . . . Had the evil course of his sons been known to him, he would have removed them without delay; but this was not what the petitioners desired."—Patriarchs and Prophets, p. 604.

5. What was the real reason for Israel's wanting a king? 1 Sam. 8:20.

This was not the first time Israel had thought of having a king. In the days of the judges, some of the men of Israel tried to make Gideon their king. (See Judges 8:22, 23.) Later the men of Shechem made Abimelech, Gideon's son, their king for a time. (See Judges 9:1-6.)

Israel's government during the period of the judges was a rather loose-knit confederacy of the twelve tribes. Politically, it was a time of turmoil when Israel was often subject to defeat. The judgeship system seemed to have failed. The arguments of the elders for combining the tribes into a monarchy for stronger military defense, and for continuity of leadership sounded logical from a human viewpoint.

The real issue was not in Israel's system of government but in her failure to obey God's laws. The future history of Israel and Judah would prove all too tragically that a monarchy would be no more effective than the spirituality and integrity of the king on the throne.

The elders seemed to forget that if the priest's sons could be vile, and the prophet's sons dishonest, the king's sons might also be corrupt. Moreover, in a monarchy it would be most difficult to change leaders.

6. What was Samuel's response to this request? What did he do? 1 Sam. 8:6.

What would you have done? Put yourself in Samuel's place. Try to imagine your own emotional reaction to this situation. Have you ever been in a similar circumstance? How did you react? Did you remember to pray?

The Real Problem. "Samuel saw that their real motive was discontent and pride, and that their demand was the result of a deliberate and determined purpose. No complaint had been made against Samuel. All acknowledged the integrity and wisdom of his administration; but the aged prophet looked upon the request as a censure upon himself, and a direct effort to set him aside. He did not, however, reveal his feelings; he uttered no reproach, but carried the matter to the Lord in prayer, and sought counsel from Him alone."—Patriarchs and Prophets, pp. 604, 605.

7. What was God's response? 1 Sam. 8:7. Read the texts below and list other instances in Israel's history when God agreed to let His people have their own way, even though it was not in their best interest.

Num. 11:4-6, 18-20, 31-34 ______

Num. 13:30-33; 14:22-24 ______

God said, in effect, "Don't feel bad, Samuel; this is the way they've been treating Me 'since the day that I brought them up out of Egypt even unto this day' " (1 Sam. 8:8).

"How often they rebelled against him in the wilderness and grieved him in the desert! Again and again they tried God's patience and provoked the Holy One of Israel" (Ps. 78:40, 41, NEB).

What have been the results in your life when God has allowed you to have your own way regarding something that you knew in your heart was not His will for you?

III. Dangers of a Monarchy (1 Sam. 8:9-22)

8. Before giving the people their request, what warning was Samuel instructed to deliver? 1 Sam. 8:9-18.

9. Contrast the excuses Israel gave for wanting a king with the warnings God gave against having one:

Why Israel Wanted a King:Why God Said It Was Not Best:
1 Sam. 8:5, 20.1 Sam. 8:11-17
Discontent with Samuel's sons.Misuse of power over subjects.
Wanted to be like the nations. (Compare Lev. 18:2-4.)King would demand best resources to enrich himself.
Wanted a king to judge them. (Compare Deut. 17:8-13.)High taxes to support a monarchy.
Wanted a king to fight their battles. (Compare Deut. 20:4; 7:18-21; 9:3.)Conscription to military would take their sons. Oppression of the people was likely. God promised to fight for them.

10. Study the following examples of the fulfillment of these predictions in the reigns of some of the kings of Israel and Judah:

  • High taxes: 1 Kings 10:25.
  • Service for the king: 1 Kings 10:25, 26.
  • Best of the land: 1 Kings 21:1-16.
  • Oppression of the people: 1 Kings 12:1-14.
  • Military conscription: 1 Chron. 21:1-4, 7.

11. What lay at the root of Israel's problem throughout history? What lessons can I learn for myself and my church? Compare Deut. 1:30-32; Ps. 78:17, 22.

Israel's failure to trust God in simple belief is seen by the psalmist as rebellion. Their insistence on a king was an outright refusal to trust God's promises of deliverance from their enemies.

12. God foresaw that Israel would want a king. What guidelines did He give to Moses in the event that happened? Deut. 17:14-20.

"Though a monarchical form of government for Israel had been foretold in prophecy, God had reserved to Himself the right to choose their king."—Patriarchs and Prophets, p. 608.

13. In the chart below rate the first three kings of Israel on the specific guidelines given in Deuteronomy 17:14-20, with an (A) for "according to God's will," (F) for "failure," and (C) for "acceptable." (Study the texts listed below the chart.)

God's Requirements for a KingSaulDavidSolomon
King to be chosen by God, v. 15
He must be an Israelite, v. 15
He must not enrich himself at expense of subjects, nor enslave them, vs. 16, 17
He must not multiply wives, v. 17
He must rule by law of God, vs. 18-20

Saul: 1 Sam. 9:15-17; 9:2; 15:9; 2 Sam. 3:7; 1 Sam. 14:24; 15:23.

David: 1 Sam. 16:1; 5:13; 8:15; 24:17; 7:25-27.

Solomon: 1 Chron. 28:5; 29:1; 1 Kings 10:14, 26-29; 11:1-4; 4:26, 27; 9:22; 11:9-11.

Although Israel wanted a king "that they might be like the other nations," their true King wanted to spare them the tyranny, serfdom, and corruption that often came with this form of government. Through Moses, God had given restrictions and sound principles that, if followed, might avoid the pitfalls of an authoritarian state. Sadly, His counsel was more often ignored than followed by Israel's future kings. The Israelites had chosen to reject God as their King. Instead of His divine assistance, they would now be subject to the hereditary succession of a line of kings that would often bring apostasy and disgrace to the nation.

14. After hearing of the dangers of a monarchy, how did the people respond? 1 Sam. 8:19, 20. What lessons for the church today can we learn from Israel's experience?

"The Israelites did not realize that to be in this respect unlike other nations was a special privilege and blessing. God had separated the Israelites from every other people, to make them His own peculiar treasure. But they, disregarding this high honor, eagerly desired to imitate the example of the heathen! And still the longing to conform to worldly practices and customs exists among the professed people of God. As they depart from the Lord, they become ambitious for the gains and honors of the world. . . . For the sake of earthly distinction they sacrifice the unspeakable honor to which God has called them."—Patriarchs and Prophets, p. 607.

15. Sometime later, when the people admitted to their sin in asking for a king, what appeal did they make to Samuel? 1 Sam. 12:19.

In many ways Samuel was a type of Christ. The people had despised his "humble authority," even as centuries later the Jewish nation would reject the humble Man of Galilee as their king, choosing Barabbas instead.

Perhaps the quality of Samuel's leadership that shines out the brightest is his intercession for his people. On several occasions the people came crying to him with the plea "Pray for us." Dedicated as he was to their spiritual welfare, he assured them in words that should burn into every leader's heart: "God forbid that I should sin against the Lord in ceasing to pray for you" (1 Sam. 12:23; compare Heb. 7:25).

16. What precious assurance did Samuel give the people at this time? 1 Sam. 12:22. What lesson does this teach us about the kind of God we serve?

The Modern Parallel. List some areas of our personal lives and our church life in which we tend to make choices similar to those of the Israelites in demanding a king to rule over them:

  • Personal choices:
  • Choices by the church:
  • What should we do to correct the situation?

Further Study and Meditation: Read the chapter, "The Schools of the Prophets" in Patriarchs and Prophets, pp. 592-602.

Summary: Samuel's dedicated ministry to Israel, and to the schools of the prophets, provides models for our church today. The story of Israel's rejection of God's system of government, their insistence on having a king, and their unbelief stand as warnings to us today. (See 1 Cor. 10:11.)

Bible texts in this lesson

1 Samuel 8:7 · 1 Samuel 7:15-17 · 1 Samuel 8:1-9 · 1 Samuel 8:9-22 · Genesis 20:7 · Numbers 12:6-8 · 1 Samuel 3:20 · 1 Samuel 7:9 · 1 Samuel 19:20 · 1 Samuel 19:18 · 1 Samuel 19:19 · 1 Samuel 8:1-5 · 1 Samuel 8:20 · Judges 8:22 · Judges 8:23 · Judges 9:1-6 · 1 Samuel 8:6 · Numbers 11:4-6 · Numbers 11:18-20 · Numbers 11:31-34 · Numbers 13:30-33 · Numbers 14:22-24 · 1 Samuel 8:8 · Psalms 78:40 · Psalms 78:41 · 1 Samuel 8:9-18 · 1 Samuel 8:5 · 1 Samuel 8:11-17 · Leviticus 18:2-4 · Deuteronomy 17:8-13 · Deuteronomy 20:4 · Deuteronomy 7:18-21 · Deuteronomy 9:3 · 1 Kings 10:25 · 1 Kings 10:26 · 1 Kings 21:1-16 · 1 Kings 12:1-14 · 1 Chronicles 21:1-4 · 1 Chronicles 21:7 · Deuteronomy 1:30-32 · Psalms 78:17 · Psalms 78:22 · Deuteronomy 17:14-20 · 1 Samuel 8:15 · 1 Samuel 8:16 · 1 Samuel 8:17 · 1 Samuel 8:18-20 · 1 Samuel 9:15-17 · 1 Samuel 9:2 · 1 Samuel 15:9 · 2 Samuel 3:7 · 1 Samuel 14:24 · 1 Samuel 15:23 · 1 Chronicles 28:5 · 1 Chronicles 29:1 · 1 Kings 10:14 · 1 Kings 10:26-29 · 1 Kings 11:1-4 · 1 Kings 4:26 · 1 Kings 4:27 · 1 Kings 9:22 · 1 Kings 11:9-11 · 1 Samuel 8:19 · 1 Samuel 12:19 · 1 Samuel 12:23 · Hebrews 7:25 · 1 Samuel 12:22 · 1 Corinthians 10:11

My notes

Saved in this browser. Sign in to see your notes on other devices.

Download lesson PDF Download quarter PDF · 13 lessons