Lesson 11 · June 16, 1990
Christian Freedom Threatened by Legalism
This Week's Study: Galatians 5:1-15.
Memory Text: "For, brethren, ye have been called unto liberty; only use not liberty for an occasion to the flesh, but by love serve one another. For all the law is fulfilled in one word, even in this; Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself" (Galatians 5:13, 14).
Faith Counters Legalism. The legalist attempts to earn salvation by personal efforts. For the legalist, obedience to the law is a means of righteousness and acceptance with God. The obedience to the law of the faithful Christian results from union with Christ. Such obedience gives evidence that faith is genuine. The legalist is judgmental of others, measuring worth by a subjective standard of holiness and failing to engage in realistic self-analysis.
Outline
I. Legalism a Spiritual Disaster (Gal. 5:1-4).
II. Faith and Works Contrasted (Gal. 5:5, 6).
III. How to Restore Erring Christians (Gal. 5:7-10).
IV. Judgment Against False Teachings (Gal. 5:11, 12).
V. Freedom and Responsibility (Gal. 5:13-15).
Works of Law or Works of Faith? A woman once asked John Wesley, "Suppose you knew that you would die tomorrow at midnight, how would you spend the time between now and then?" Wesley replied, "Why madam, just as I intend to spend it now. I would preach this evening at Gloucester, and again at five tomorrow morning; after that I would ride to Tewkesbury, preach in the afternoon, and meet the societies in the evening. I would then go to Martin's house, who expects to entertain me, talk and pray with the family as usual, retire to my room at 10 o'clock, commend myself to my heavenly Father, lie down to rest, and wake up in Glory."
Wesley's life was filled with busy activities that can be described as works of faith. He was not serving God and humanity to earn righteousness and salvation, but because he knew that Christ had bestowed righteousness and salvation upon him.
Works of faith are spoken of by James in chapter 2 of his Epistle. (Compare Gal. 5:6; Rom. 2:13.) They are works that result from faith and give evidence that genuine faith is present. Works of faith result from Christ living out His life through the believing Christian (Gal. 2:20).
Works of law. In Galatians and Romans, Paul opposes works of law. These are works that are not performed by faith in Christ, but for the express purpose of improving one's standing with God. The Galatians had capitulated to the process of performing religious exercises with the intention of earning justification. Paul reminded them that Christian liberty sets us free from such legalism and makes possible works that are acceptable in the sight of God.
I. Legalism a Spiritual Disaster (Gal. 5:1-4)
1. What do you think Paul means in the statement recorded in Galatians 5:1?
Legalism then and now. The New International. Version translates the verse: "It is for freedom that Christ has set us free. Stand firm, then, and do not let yourselves be burdened again by a yoke of slavery." The word bondage (KJV) must be understood in light of chapter 4, where Paul uses the terms "servant" (slave) and "bondmaid" to refer to the old life before Christ. In both analogies, Paul understood acceptance of Judaism to be a return to bondage. (See chapter 4:9.) Few Christians today are tempted to accept Judaism. This does not mean, however, that Galatians 5:1 has become irrelevant. Legalism in any form is a return to bondage similar to that which Paul opposed.
2. Why do you think Paul opposed circumcision so forcefully? Gal. 5:2, 3.
Circumcision was a symbol of circumcision of the heart. (See Deut. 10:16; 30:6; Rom. 2:25-29.) Circumcision of the heart is the new birth experience given to those who accept Christ as Saviour and Lord. (See Col. 2:10, 11.) To continue the practice of circumcision as a religious ceremony was to deny that the symbol had met its fulfillment in Christ. It was a way of saying that Christ's provision at the cross is insufficient.
Circumcision served a temporary purpose. "If man had kept the law of God, as given to Adam after his fall, preserved by Noah, and observed by Abraham, there would have been no necessity for the ordinance of circumcision."—Patriarchs and Prophets, p. 364.
3. What serious consequence befalls the Christian who looks to the law for salvation? Gal. 5:4.
Once saved always saved? Paul now comes to the basic reason for his letter to the Galatians. Their relationship with Christ was being severed by false teachings and practices. A hope of salvation built upon one's own efforts is a false hope. The Galatians were nullifying the grace that God had given them.
Some Christians today teach that once a person has been saved he cannot be lost. "Those who apostatize were not converted in the first place," we are sometimes told. However, the whole tenor of Galatians suggests that this is a false supposition. Paul said that the Galatian Christians first received the Holy Spirit by faith (Gal. 3:1-5). He reminded them of the joy they had found in their new faith (Gal. 4:15). He wrote, "You were running a good race" (Gal. 5:7, NIV). The Galatian church members were genuinely converted Christians at the time Paul concluded his evangelistic efforts among them.
The promise of eternal life can be forfeited through apostasy or neglect; and, as Paul points out, it can also be lost through legalism. (See Gal. 5:4.) Legalism is particularly dangerous to spiritual health because it comes clothed in an air of piety and apparent concern for the very salvation that it destroys.
Reflections on legalism.
- Have you ever seen a Christian in bondage to his religious practices? Have you ever felt like a slave to your own standards? Was it the fault of the standards, or of your chosen means of achieving them? * What is the difference between legalism and the effort to uphold standards of Christian behavior in diet, dress, and entertainment?
II. Faith and Works Contrasted (Gal. 5:5, 6)
4. What does Paul say the Christian waits for? Does the believer have to wait for righteousness? Gal. 5:5; Rom. 8:9, 10; 1 John 3:7.
"In all the six other instances where this word [the verb 'to wait for'] appears (Rom. 8:19, 23, 25; 1 Cor. 1:7; Phil. 3:20; Heb. 9:28) it is used of waiting or looking for the coming of Jesus and the resurrection.
"Hope of righteousness. That is, the hope made possible through righteousness. Paul does not imply that those who have received the Spirit must wait for righteousness. They 'wait for the hope' imparted by righteousness, the hope of the completion of the plan of salvation at the return of Jesus and the resurrection of the dead (Rom. 8:23; Titus 2:13). Paul consistently speaks of justification as a completed work in the life of the Christian (Rom. 5:1; etc.; see on Matt. 5:48)."—SDA Bible Commentary, vol. 6, p. 977.
We add that justification is a completed work that is renewed daily as we enjoy the blessings of a daily revitalization of our relationship with Christ. (See 2 Cor. 4:16.)
5. What contrast does Paul make in verse 6?
Not ______ nor ______
but ______
Faith and works. Paul here suggests what a few verses later becomes the theme of the last part of his letter to the Galatians. While he is strenuously opposed to works as a means of attaining righteousness, he clearly recognizes the importance of works that are motivated by love as a product of faith.
"At this point the teachings of Paul and James meet. The two are not in conflict, as some have hastily concluded. . . . It is a counterfeit faith that leads a man to think himself released from obedience to the will of God as expressed in the Decalogue, which is simply a brief outline of how love toward God and man will find expression. . . . Obedience to known duty is an inevitable result of the righteousness that comes by faith, and is the supreme test of its genuineness."—SDA Bible Commentary, vol. 6, p. 978.
III. How to Restore Erring Christians (Gal. 5:7-10)
6. From our study so far this quarter, who do you think hindered the Galatians from obeying the truth? Gal. 5:7.
A good beginning. At the beginning of their Christian race the Galatian Christians had been filled with faith, and because of this they were obedient to the truth. Faith makes possible obedience and good works. The teachings of the Jewish party, with their strong emphasis on obeying the law, weakened and, perhaps for some, even destroyed faith. The result was actually disastrous to the very obedience the Jewish party was so intent on achieving. Any effort to gain righteousness by obedience results in disobedience.
7. Who do you think had called the Galatian Christians—God or Paul? Gal. 5:8; compare Rom. 8:29, 30.
8. What is the effect upon the church as a whole of one erroneous teaching? Gal. 5:9.
9. What encouragement did Paul now offer the Galatian Christians? Gal. 5:10 (first part).
Blend in confidence. There are times when we must warn others of danger. Jesus commanded His disciples to speak personally to any brother they found in error. (See Matt. 18:15.) God told Ezekiel that those who fail to warn others of sin will be required to share the penalty for that sin. (See Eze. 3:17, 18.) Thus far in his Epistle Paul has faithfully warned—indeed rebuked—the Galatian Christians, even to the point of calling them foolish for departing from the faith. (See Gal. 3:1.)
However, warnings that only point out error can quickly degenerate into destructive criticism. Paul shows us that along with the warning we must blend in an expression of confidence that the erring one will make the right change.
Reflection. Can you think of a time when a church successfully restored an erring member? Write down the steps that church took.
IV. Judgment Against False Teachings (Gal. 5:11, 12)
10. Who would judge those who were troubling the Galatians? Gal. 5:10 (second part). Compare Eccl. 12:13, 14; James 2:12.
The Bible teaches judgment. The New Age movement that is rapidly gaining ground in Western culture teaches that there is no such thing as a final judgment against sin. Indeed, according to the New Age, there is no such thing as sin. People should create their own moral standards, its proponents say, based on the wisdom inherent in themselves. The only evil is ignorance, not immorality. Human beings were made to be free. Any externally imposed moral code is slavery.
According to the Bible and the insights offered by Ellen White, this is the same line of reasoning that Satan advanced in heaven. The Bible teaches that human beings are subject to law—God's law—and that there will be a final judgment based on that law. Paul now makes it clear that legalism, and the effort to ensnare others in legalism, is just as much a sin as out-and-out immorality, and also is subject to the final judgment.
11. What claim did the Jewish party apparently make about Paul? Gal. 5:11.
A preposterous suggestion. Preposterous as it may seem, the Jewish party in Galatia apparently claimed that Paul still supported circumcision for religious reasons, perhaps because he had encouraged Timothy, a half-Jew, to be circumcised. (See Acts 16:1-3.) The SDA Bible Commentary suggests that the Jewish party advanced this claim in an effort to make Paul seem inconsistent (vol. 6, p. 979). Another possibility is that, recognizing Paul's powerful influence, they may have tried to "get him on their side"—as though to say, "See, even Paul agrees with us." Paul's logic quickly put a fast end to that argument: "If I support circumcision, why am I still being persecuted for opposing it?"
12. What wish does Paul express for the Jewish party? Gal. 5:12.
A figurative statement. According to the SDA Bible Commentary, the Greek word Paul uses here, which is translated "cut off" in the King James Version, is never used in reference to cutting a person off from church fellowship. Rather, it means to dismember one's self, and is sometimes used of castration. "Paul suggests that the Judaizers, who advocate circumcision, might as well castrate themselves. If a measure of virtue can be secured by circumcision, one should be able to obtain even more by castration! "—SDA Bible Commentary, vol. 6, p. 969. We must, of course, understand this as a figurative statement, similar to Christ's deliberate exaggeration in Matthew 5:29: "If your right eye causes you to sin, gouge it out and throw it away. It is better for you to lose one part of your body than for your whole body to be thrown into hell" (NIV).
Looking at life today.
- How would you respond to the argument that a loving God would never judge or condemn anyone?
- What are some modern teachings (sincerely held by some Christians) that you believe God will condemn in the judgment?• Will He also condemn those who teach such views? What biblical evidence can you give for your answer?
V. Freedom and Responsibility (Gal. 5:13-15)
13. How can Christians abuse freedom? Gal. 5:13.
Law is a guide to freedom. The New International Version says, "You, my brothers, were called to be free. But do not use your freedom to indulge the sinful nature; rather, serve one another in love." This passage helps us to understand the proper relationship between law and faith. Law condemns those things that the sinful nature would lead us to indulge. Paul might have said, "You were called to be free, but do not use your freedom as an excuse to break the law." Christians are not free of the obligation to live a holy life in conformity with law. They are delivered from legalism. They are not delivered from obedience, but from obedience as a way to gain God's favor.
14. How is the law related to service? Gal. 5:13, 14.
15. On the other hand, how does legalism affect our relationships to others? Gal. 5:15.
Obedience, legalism, and service. Obedience and legalism are opposites. Obedience and faith go hand in hand on one side, legalism and presumption on the other. Those who bring their impulses under the control of God's law are able to serve one another in love. Apparently, the Galatian Christians were not doing that. Galatians 5:15 informs us that they were biting and devouring one another. This is probably a reference to criticism, condemnation, and harsh judgment—common characteristics of legalistic people. Legalists cannot bless others. They cannot serve the church or the world. Only those whose hearts have been transformed by Christ's grace, who obey God's law out of love for others, can do that.
The Message Applied
- 1.If I recognize legalism in myself, what should I do? List three options on the lines below: 2. Complete this open-ended sentence: The best way to help others who manifest a legalistic attitude is to ______ 3. I can be concerned about maintaining the church's high standards and not be legalistic. Agree / / Disagree / /
Notes
Further Study and Meditation: Read the chapters entitled "Warnings Against Sensational Teachings and Emotional Religion" and "Earmarks of Erroneous Teaching" in Selected Messages, book 2, pp. 13-24, 80-84.
Summary: Legalism is one of the most dangerous sins because those who yield to it think they are doing right. The legalists whom Paul was addressing wished to "restore" the erring and purify the church of false teachings. They thought that obedience to their rules would provide salvation for the Galatians. The legalist sets himself up as the final judge of right and wrong. However, only those whose hearts have been transformed by Christ can judge between right and wrong in a way that will win souls rather than alienate them.
Bible texts in this lesson
Galatians 5:1-15 · Galatians 5:13 · Galatians 5:14 · Galatians 5:1-4 · Galatians 5:5 · Galatians 5:6 · Galatians 5:7-10 · Galatians 5:11 · Galatians 5:12 · Galatians 5:13-15 · Romans 2:13 · Galatians 2:20 · Galatians 5:1 · Galatians 4:9 · Galatians 5:2 · Galatians 5:3 · Deuteronomy 10:16 · Deuteronomy 30:6 · Romans 2:25-29 · Colossians 2:10 · Colossians 2:11 · Galatians 5:4 · Galatians 3:1-5 · Galatians 4:15 · Galatians 5:7 · Romans 8:9 · Romans 8:10 · 1 John 3:7 · Romans 8:19 · Romans 8:23 · Romans 8:25 · 1 Corinthians 1:7 · Philippians 3:20 · Hebrews 9:28 · Titus 2:13 · Romans 5:1 · Matthew 5:48 · 2 Corinthians 4:16 · Galatians 5:8 · Romans 8:29 · Romans 8:30 · Galatians 5:9 · Galatians 5:10 · Matthew 18:15 · Ezekiel 3:17 · Ezekiel 3:18 · Galatians 3:1 · Ecclesiastes 12:13 · Ecclesiastes 12:14 · James 2:12 · Acts 16:1-3 · Matthew 5:29 · Galatians 5:15
My notes
Saved in this browser. Sign in to see your notes on other devices.