Lesson 12 · December 17, 1988
God Tells Us About Death and Resurrection
Fa. MEMORY TEXT: "For since by man came death, by man came
also the resurrection of the dead. For as in Adam all die, even so
in Christ shall all be made alive" (1 Cor. 15:21, 22).
Central Teaching: "Death and Resurrection. The wages of sin is death. But God, who alone is immortal, will grant eternal life to His redeemed. Until that day death is an unconscious state for all people. When Christ, who is our life, appears, the resurrected righteous and the living righteous will be glorified and caught up to meet their Lord. The second resurrection, the resurrection of the unrighteous, will take place a thousand years later."—Fundamental Belief No. 25.
Outline
I. What Did Jesus and Bible Prophets Teach About Death?
II. Where Are the Dead?
III. What Is a Human "Spirit"?
IV. What Is a "Soul"? Is It Immortal?
V. Will the Dead Live Again?
Introduction: There is great interest today in the subject of life after death. The weekly national newspapers at supermarket checkout stands often have stories and pictures of people who allegedly experienced life after being pronounced clinically dead. When they were revived they told their stories. The concept of life after death is also very vividly portrayed in some television programs.
At various times and places during the past century, studies have been conducted suggesting that there is life immediately after death. The idea of the immortality of the soul has pervaded the religions and philosophies of mankind for many centuries. The Chinese built mansions, veritable ghost towns, to house the spirits of their ancestors. Buddhists believe in transmigration of the soul to other bodies. Hindus also believe in spirit migration, a reincarnation through other births.
These Eastern philosophies are becoming very influential in the West. Certain organizations and movements, some Christian and some non-Christian, are giving credence to the immortal-soul concept.
It is vitally important to know the truth of this subject as a safeguard against the onslaught of spiritistic philosophies and religions that are gripping masses of Christians and non-Christians. What happens when a person dies? Does his soul go to heaven or hell? Does it stay in the grave? Does the dead person know what is happening on earth? Can he, as many people believe, communicate with his living loved ones? Where are the dead? Will the circumstances of the dead ever change, or is death the end of it all? Is there life immediately after death, or later, or never?
Philosophers have come up with all kinds of theories on this subject. The doctrine of the immortality of the soul taught by the ancient Greek philosopher Plato (about 427-347 B.C.) very much influenced Jewish thought in the Hellenistic period. As a result, the Jewish Pharisees believed in the immortality of the soul. The Alexandrian Jew Philo, who wrote in the first century A.D., had a considerable influence on early Christian theologians, such as Origen (about A.D. 185-254). Hence, the Greek philosophical teaching of the immortality of the soul became largely accepted by Christians.
We are interested in what the Bible teaches. Only God knows the true condition of those who have died. We turn to God for the answer.
I. What Did Jesus and Bible Prophets Teach About Death?
How did Christ's greatest miracle, the raising of Lazarus, reveal the state of man in death? What did Jesus call death? John 11:6, 7, 11-14.
Search and Learn: Compare the following Bible passages with Jesus' teaching on the state of man in death:
- Deut. 31:16
- Job 7:21; 14:10-12
- Dan. 12.2
- Matt. 27:52
- Mark 5:39
- Acts 7:60
Never did Jesus or any of the Bible writers suggest that part of man sleeps at death while another part goes on living in a conscious state. Never do they even imply that death is not, like sleep, a state of unconsciousness. When the Bible writers faced death they did not expect to be conscious living beings again until, by a divine miracle, their existence was restored.
According to the inspired wise man, how much knowledge do the dead have? Eccl. 9:5, 6, 10.
What did Job teach about the knowledge dead people have of their living loved ones? Job 14:21.
What knowledge of God do the dead have? Do they praise God? Psalms 6:5; 115:17.
The Bible teaches that the dead are sleeping, without any awareness of what is happening on earth or in heaven. They do not praise God because they cannot. If the good were in heaven immediately after death, wouldn't they praise the Lord?
The parable of the rich man and Lazarus (Luke 16:19-31) is often used as evidence of life in either heaven or hell immediately after death. The parable is simply designed to teach the danger of covetousness. It offers no support for the doctrine of the immortality of the soul. If the parable is interpreted literally it becomes an absurdity.
For example, the beggar went to "Abraham's bosom." Obviously that is a symbol. Abraham would have needed a very large chest to literally accommodate all the righteous dead. The rich man in hell spoke of Lazarus' finger, and his own tongue. In this parable the dead have bodies. But immortal soul advocates believe that the souls of the dead are disembodied. Who imagines that it is possible for the good in heaven to converse with the wicked in hell, as they do in this parable? The rich man wanted Lazarus to go to his living brothers and warn them. The only way that could happen, according to this story, would be if "one rose from the dead" (Luke 16:31). That is quite different from the popular idea that dead souls can communicate with the living without a resurrection being necessary.
Jesus was using a popular fable as a sermon illustration. He was not teaching life immediately after death, or the doctrine of the immortality of the soul. The first-century Jewish historian Josephus tells much the same fable in other words. (See "An Extract out of Josephus's Discourse to the Greeks Concerning Hades" in Josephus—Complete Works, translated by William Whiston (Grand Rapids, Mich.: Kregel, 1960), pp. 637, 638).
II. Where Are the Dead?
The Bible explains where the dead are not, as well as where they are.
Where did David not go when he died, despite the fact that he was a righteous man whose sins had been forgiven? Acts 2:29, 34.
In his great sermon on the Day of Pentecost, the apostle Peter. explained that David's statement in Psalm 16 was a reference to the Messiah, not to David himself (Acts 2:24-33). Peter pointed out that David was dead and buried, and his grave was there for everyone to see. Christ rose from the dead and ascended to heaven, but David remained in the grave, where he saw corruption. David was a righteous man, but he did not go to heaven when he died.
The Bible nowhere teaches that believers in Christ go to heaven when they die.
According to Isaiah, where are the dead? Isa. 26:19.
Where would be Job's place of waiting for the change that only God can bring to the dead? Job 14:14; 17:13-16.
Where are the dead? Job and Isaiah answer very positively. The dead are in the dust of the.earth, resting in their graves, waiting for the great change that Jesus promised would come at the end of time.
Death need have no fears for the believer in Christ. Because it is a state of unconsciousness, he or she.will rest sweetly until the call of the Lifegiver. If the dead were in heaven seeing the struggles of their loved ones on earth, how could they ever be happy? If they were in hell, suffering for long periods of time until the second coming of the Lord, it would be difficult to understand how a God of love could bring such protracted suffering. It would seem that the punishment would be very much in excess of the crime; even though some people have been very wicked.
III. What Is a Human "Spirit"?
It is believed by many Christians that there is in each person an immortal, immaterial part that does not sleep when the body dies. The "spirit" of an individual is thought to go on living either in heaven or hell. Does the Bible teach this view?
What were the component parts of man given by God at creation? Gen. 2:7.
What happens to these components when a person dies? Psalm 146:3, 4; Eccl. 12:7.
What gift from God do animals share with man? Gen. 7:15, 21, 22; Eccl. 3:19-21.
The breath of life given to man at creation was the life principle, or life force that gave life to the body and existence to the individual. When a person dies the opposite process takes place. The breath of life (spirit) goes back to God, and the body goes back to the dust of the earth. The words "breath" (Psalm 146:4) and "spirit" (Eccl. 12:7) are a translation of the Hebrew word ruach. The Greek equivalent used in the New Testament is pneuma. These words have a number of meanings:
(i) Breath of the mouth (Psalm 33:6; Dan. 10:17; 2 Thess. 2:8).
(ii) Breath of air, wind, soft breeze (Ex. 14:21; John 3:8).
(iii) The Spirit of God (Gen. 1:2; John 14:17).
(iv) An evil spirit (1 Sam. 16:23; Luke 11:24).
(v) The principle that gives life to the body (Gen. 6:17; 7:15; Luke 8:55).
(vi) The emotions, intellectual functions, and attitudes of the will
(Gen. 41:8; Deut. 34:9; 1 Cor. 2:11; 2 Cor. 2:13).
Never in Scripture is the "spirit" of man said to survive the death of the body as an immortal, conscious entity. In Ecclesiastes 3:19-21 the "spirit" is the life force implanted by God at Creation and shared by every living thing, whether man or animal.
Some interpreters of the Bible try to use Ecclesiastes 12:7 to prove that the immortal spirits of good people go to heaven when they die. If the spirit in this verse is man's immortal soul, then the souls of all people, good and bad, must go to heaven when they die. No one believes that the spirits of evil men ascend to heaven.at death.
The text simply teaches that the life principle given by God to a person is taken back by God when the individual dies. The doctrine of the immortality of the soul is not even implied.
Both Old and New Testaments sometimes use the word "spirit" to refer to the mind of man, his capacity to reason, as well as his ability to feel and choose. (See Dan. 2:1; 5:12; Matt. 26:41; Rom. 1:9.) Such intellectual and emotional faculties never survive the death of the body. In this sense, the spirit is the inner life that is totally dependent upon the existence of the body. As we have seen, the dead person has no further reasoning powers, emotions, or powers of the will. Because the life force has been taken away from him, he has ceased to be a living person.
IV. What Is a "Soul"? Is It Immortal?
Did God create an immortal soul for man? Genesis 2:7 says that the body + the breath of life = "a living soul."
That implies that if the breath of life were withdrawn man would be a dead soul. If souls can die, they are not immortal. Immortality is the capacity never to die.
Search and Learn: What do the following passages teach regarding the soul?
- Ezek. 18.4
- Rev. 16.3
- Num 6.6
- Matt. 10:28
- Gen. 1:20, 21, 24, 30; 2:19
The Hebrew word for soul used in the Old Testament is nephesh. The Greek equivalent used in the New Testament is psuche. The word body in the King James Version of Numbers 6:6 translates the Hebrew word for "soul." The word "creature" is used to translate the Hebrew word for "soul" in the King James Version of Gen. 1:20, 21, 30; 2:19; 9:10, 12, 15, 16. In all of those passages animals are spoken of as souls. God made animals living souls just as He made man a living soul. He formed animals from the dust and breathed into their nostrils the breath of life. Like man, when the animals die, they are dead souls.
Comparing man with God, who only has immortality? 1 Tim. 6:15, 16.
Because God "only hath immortality," human souls are not immortal. As we have seen, the human soul is composed of two parts: the body and the breath. Without the one the other cannot exist. The death of the body is the death of the soul.
Kittel's Theological Dictionary of the New Testament comments on the Hebrew word for "soul" (nephesh): The soul "has no existence apart from the body. Hence the best translation in many instances is 'person' comprised in corporeal reality. The person can be marked off and counted, Gen. 12:5; 46:18; Jos. 10:28; 11:11. Each individual is a nephesh [soul] and when the texts speak of a single nephesh [soul] for a totality, the totality is viewed as a single person, a 'corporate personality.' Hence nephesh [soul] can denote what is most individual in human nature, namely the ego, and it can become a synonym for the personal pronoun, Gn. 27:25." Volume IX, p. 620.
The New Testament Greek word for soul (psuche) has meanings similar to those of the Old Testament word. It is often best translated by "life." A human life is a "soul." (See Mark 3:4; 8:35 where the King James Version translates the Greek word for "soul" by "life.")
Nowhere in the Scriptures is the soul spoken of as a disembodied immortal entity in heaven or hell. The soul is the total personality or part of it. Sometimes when the word soul is used it refers to the spiritual self, or the intellectual or emotional self. But these aspects of soul are not conceived as ever separate from the physical self. When the body dies so do the other faculties of the soul. What is preserved for the believer is God's knowledge of his faithfulness, and God's promise that he will have eternal life at the second coming of Jesus.
V. Will the Dead Live Again?
Search and Learn: What do the following passages teach regarding the resurrection of the dead:
- John 5:28, 29
- Acts 24:15
- 1 Cor. 15:16-22, 51-54
- 2 Cor. 4:14
- 1 Thess. 4:13-18
There are two resurrections: (1) "the resurrection of life," which is the resurrection of the "just," (2) "the resurrection of damnation," which is the resurrection of the "unjust." The first resurrection takes place at the second coming of Jesus. This is when all of Christ's faithful people, those who are raised from the dead and those who are translated without seeing death, are given immortality. All of these faithful ones are taken to heaven with perfect bodies and minds. (See John 14:1-3; Rev. 7:13-17; The Great Controversy, pp. 644, 645.) The second resurrection, in which those are raised who died unbelieving, takes place 1,000 years later. (See Rev. 20:5, first part, 7-9.) The lost are never given immortality. They are consumed in the fires of the last great day. They do not live on to suffer for eternity. (See Mal. 4:1, 3; Psalms 37:10, 20; 68:1, 2; Jude 13; 2 Peter 2:17.)
Further Study and Meditation: On the meaning of "everlasting destruction" (2 Thess. 1:9) compare: Jude 7; 2 Peter 2:6; Jer. 17:27; 2 Chron. 36:19, 21. On the meaning of "forever" (Rev. 14:11; 20:10) compare: Jonah 2:6; 1:17; Matt. 12:40; 2 Kings 5:27; Ex. 12:24. On the danger of the immortal soul doctrine read The Great Controversy, pages 531-562.
What Others Teach: For centuries most of the Christian world has espoused the immortal soul doctrine. Today the vast majority of Christian churches teach that the soul is immortal and that the reward in heaven or hell is received at death. Belief in limbo and purgatory is founded on this false doctrine.
How to Share This Truth with Others: Most Christians to whom you witness believe in the immortality of the soul. Unless dealt with very sensitively, presentation of the Bible teaching on this subject can cause considerable conflict. Attempt to discover what the individual believes about death before sharing your belief. Place the emphasis on life in Christ Jesus and the hope of the resurrection. Never use crude illustrations. Do not immediately contradict a person's belief that he or she has communicated with the dead. First present the resurrection. Then gradually and tactfully open up the truths found in this lesson. If you sense that an individual is upset, immediately bring your study to a close and talk about hope in Christ and the resurrection. Do not attempt to give the whole doctrine at one time to people who firmly believe in the immortality of the soul.
Summary: Seventh-day Adventists believe that, because of Calvary, death is a temporary sleep for all human beings. There is no immortal part of man that lives on after the death of the body. At the second coming of Jesus, the righteous dead are raised and, along with their living brethren, given immortality. At the end of the 1,000 years, the wicked are raised, punished according to their works, and put to sleep for eternity.
Application
- Have I put away my fear of death because of Jesus' promise to raise me from the dead?
- Am I committed to warning others of the deceptions involved in the doctrine of the immortality of the soul?
Bible texts in this lesson
1 Corinthians 15:21 · 1 Corinthians 15:22 · John 11:6 · John 11:7 · John 11:11-14 · Deuteronomy 31:16 · Job 7:21 · Job 14:10-12 · Daniel 12 · Matthew 27:52 · Mark 5:39 · Acts 7:60 · Ecclesiastes 9:5 · Ecclesiastes 9:6 · Ecclesiastes 9:10 · Job 14:21 · Psalms 6:5 · Psalms 115:17 · Luke 16:19-31 · Luke 16:31 · Acts 2:29 · Acts 2:34 · Psalms 16 · Acts 2:24-33 · Isaiah 26:19 · Job 14:14 · Job 17:13-16 · Genesis 2:7 · Psalms 146:3 · Psalms 146:4 · Ecclesiastes 12:7 · Genesis 7:15 · Genesis 7:21 · Genesis 7:22 · Ecclesiastes 3:19-21 · Psalms 33:6 · Daniel 10:17 · 2 Thessalonians 2:8 · Exodus 14:21 · John 3:8 · Genesis 1:2 · John 14:17 · 1 Samuel 16:23 · Luke 11:24 · Genesis 6:17 · Luke 8:55 · Genesis 41:8 · Deuteronomy 34:9 · 1 Corinthians 2:11 · 2 Corinthians 2:13 · Daniel 2:1 · Daniel 5:12 · Matthew 26:41 · Romans 1:9 · Ezekiel 18 · Revelation 16 · Numbers 6 · Matthew 10:28 · Genesis 1:20 · Genesis 1:21 · Genesis 1:24 · Genesis 1:30 · Genesis 2:19 · Numbers 6:6 · Genesis 9:10 · Genesis 9:12 · Genesis 9:15 · Genesis 9:16 · 1 Timothy 6:15 · 1 Timothy 6:16 · Genesis 12:5 · Genesis 46:18 · Joshua 10:28 · Joshua 11:11 · Mark 3:4 · Mark 8:35 · John 5:28 · John 5:29 · John 14:1-3 · Revelation 7:13-17 · Revelation 20:5 · Malachi 4:1 · Malachi 4:3 · Psalms 37:10 · Psalms 37:20 · Psalms 68:1 · Psalms 68:2 · Jude 1:13 · 2 Peter 2:17 · 2 Thessalonians 1:9 · Jude 1:7 · 2 Peter 2:6 · Jeremiah 17:27 · 2 Chronicles 36:19 · 2 Chronicles 36:21 · Revelation 14:11 · Revelation 20:10 · Jonah 2:6 · Jonah 1:17 · Matthew 12:40 · 2 Kings 5:27 · Exodus 12:24
My notes
Saved in this browser. Sign in to see your notes on other devices.