Lesson 10 · December 5, 1987
Sin's Blind Hatred
This Week's Study: Esther 3:1-15.
Memory Text: "Be not deceived; God is not mocked: for whatsoever a man soweth, that shall he also reap" (Gal. 6:7).
Central Thought: Scripture does not explain why Haman hated Mordecai and his people. Even if we could have read the prime minister's mind and known his motivations, it still would not have made sense to us. Sin has no reason for existence. But as soon as it came into being, it sought to destroy all that represented good. In the book of Esther, we see one more powerful illustration of the conflict between good and evil. Although evil may seem for awhile to triumph, God and good eventually will conquer.
Overview: Esther 3:1-15
| 3:1-5 | 3:6-11 | 3:12-15 |
|---|---|---|
| Mordecai refuses to bow to Haman | Haman plots to destroy the Jews | Decree sent out; Haman and the king drink a toast |
Introduction: This week we encounter one of the unexplainable results of sin—blind, unreasoning, irrational hatred that leads to persecution. An official of the Persian government conceives a plan for destroying an entire people. But other than the fact that he has been offended because a member of that ethnic group refused to honor him in the way Haman thought was his due, we are given no reason why he should take his spite out on an entire people. We can and will offer some suggestions, but ultimately, we must admit that persecution really makes no sense.
That is the nature of sin—it makes no sense. Ellen White wrote that sin "is mysterious, unaccountable" (The Great Controversy, p. 493). "It is impossible to explain the origin of sin so as to give a reason for its existence" (The Great Controversy, p. 492). The things that sin motivates men and women to do also are unexplainable. Sin drove Haman to seek the destruction of God's people, but saying that does not explain it. As far as we know, the body of God's people had done nothing to him. Why should he lust for their total destruction? But that is the nature of sin.
The persecution of God's people during the last days will make no more sense. We say that evil hates good. But why should it? Why cannot evil just ignore good? Why should it go out of its way to destroy those who are good? Evil's drive to persecute is incomprehensible. Perhaps that is why the author of Esther is vague about the motivations of Haman and Mordecai. He does not want to cloud the picture with explanations and reasons that do not truly explain. The author wants us to grasp clearly the fact that Haman's persecution is, in the last analysis, something monstrous and without reason.
I. Mordecai Refuses to Bow to Haman (Esther 3:1-5)
What high honor did the king give Haman? Verse 1.
Jewish tradition holds that the title "Agagite" indicates that Haman was a descendant of King Agag. If that were so what would be the implications in the light of 1 Samuel 15:1-35?
Ancient Jewish commentators saw in the term "the Agagite" a continuation of the conflict between Saul and the king of the Amalekites. They speculated that the king fathered a child just before his execution, and that this child founded a line that ultimately led to Haman. Because Mordecai was of the tribe of Benjamin, they considered him to be a descendant of Saul. If this were so, the struggle between the two kings was once more resumed. However, some commentators are doubtful about this possibility: "The names Hammedatha (Haman's father), Haman, and those of Haman's ten sons (Es. 9:7-9) are all good Persian ones, and there is nothing in Agagite that is necessarily not Persian. "— H. L. Ellison, From Babylon to Bethlehem (Grand Rapids, Mich.: Baker Book House, 1984), p. 58.
The Septuagint, the ancient Greek translation of the Old Testament, renders Agagite as "bully," the "Bugaean," and "the Macedonian," and in one manuscript as the "Gogite." Even if Haman was a descendant of the Amalekites, would that justify and explain his hatred?
What interfered with Haman's enjoyment of his new honor? Esther 3:2.
"Perhaps Haman had been elevated from a low position. The special command required that all, even those who previously had outranked Haman, should now fall prostrate before him. "—SDA Bible Commentary, vol. 3, p. 472.
Illumination: "Mordecai had done Haman no harm, but had simply refused to show him worshipful reverence. "—Prophets and Kings, p. 600.
Search and Learn: Prostration before superiors was a universal custom. Notice what the following texts have to say about this practice:
- 1.1 Sam. 24:8 2. 2 Sam. 14:4
- 3.1 Kings 1:16
Notes
The Jewish Targums suggest that Haman claimed divine powers. If that were so, it would explain Ellen White's comment that he expected worshipful reverence. The Targums also suggest that Haman wore an idol on his clothing. But the fact is that the author of the book of Esther did not choose to explain why Mordecai refused to bow to Haman. Perhaps he omitted the reason in order to stress the irrationality of persecution.
What is suggested by the comments of Mordecai's fellow attendants at court? Esther 3:3, 4.
These verses suggest that the king's servants were aware of Haman's hatred for the Jews.
Illumination: "The persistent attempt made to secure Mordecai's compliance with the edict to bow before Haman implies that his fellow officials esteemed him highly. They sought to give [Mordecai] a fair opportunity before reporting the matter. From their point of view it was a serious precedent—if one royal decree could thus be flouted, how about others?"—SDA Bible Commentary, vol. 3, p. 472.
What was Haman's reaction when he discovered Mordecai's refusal to bow down? Esther 3:5.
Because we read the book of Esther in translation, we miss many of the literary touches and techniques the author uses. Here, for example, the author plays on the similarity of sound between the name of Haman and the Hebrew word for wrath, hema.
II. Haman Plots to Destroy the Jews (Esther 3:6-11)
1. The Plot Developed (Esther 3:6, 7)
In seeking the best way to destroy the Jews, Haman sought the good will of his gods. Seeking a "lucky" day for the success of his plans, he began casting lots. Day by day and month by month, the lots were cast. Finally, the date was fixed: the thirteenth day of the twelfth month, a day almost a year in the future. (It corresponds to our month of March.)
Why did Haman seek revenge on Mordecai by deciding to try to exterminate the entire Jewish race?
In ancient times, people did not have the strong individualism shared by many in the world today. People thought of themselves not as individuals but as members of a family, tribe, ethnic group, or nation. Their sense of identity was determined and shaped by the group into which they were born. They shared the group's rewards and punishments. Also what they did brought either honor or shame to the group. We call this type of thinking "corporate identity." The story of Achan (Joshua 7) graphically illustrates how this type of society responds to a problem. Achan was not just a solitary Israelite—he was part of a family, a tribe, a people. The larger group shared responsibility for the actions of an individual within it. A man or woman in the ancient world—and many parts of the world even today—was not an individual in the modem sense, but a component cell within a larger organism. What the larger group he belonged to did shaped him or her, and what he or she did affected the honor and reputation of the larger group.
Thus Haman did not just see Mordecai the individual, but also Mordecai the representative and part of the larger body of Jews. In a world of corporate identity, one got revenge against someone not just by attacking a single person, but the entire group from which the person came. We see this principle at work in world affairs even today.
But regardless of this fact, Haman's revenge for his hurt dignity was far out of proportion to the actual slight.
What does it mean to cast pur? Esther 3:7.
Some scholars used to suggest that the Jews made up the word pur just to explain the origin of the festival name Purim. Because they considered the story of Esther to be fiction, they did not believe the definition of pur found in Esther 3:7. But now we know that the word pur did mean "lot," and that ancient people cast lots in the way the book of Esther describes. A cube-shaped die in the Yale archeological collection has an inscription that twice uses the word puru, "lot." Known as "the die of lahali," a high official of Shalmaneser III (an Assyrian king ruling from 858 to 824 B.C.), "it is the only cube that has survived to this day from the time when lots were cast annually in the selection and installation of the 'eponym official,' whose name was used in chronological tables to signify a certain year of a king's reign. "—W. W. Hallo, "The First Purim," Biblical Archeologist, vol. 46, no. 1 (1983), p. 22. While the story of Esther took place some centuries later and Haman cast lots for a slightly different purpose, "the terminology and the underlying technique remain the same. "—Biblical Archaeologist, vol. 46, no. 1 (1983), p. 22. A chance archeological discovery has provided historical confirmation of the ancient practice recorded in Scripture.
2. The Plot Outlined (Esther 3:8-11)
What accusations did Haman make against the Jews when requesting their destruction? Were his accusations true? Esther 3:8.
"This charge was not true with respect to laws in general. It was only when a royal edict required a Jew to violate his religious beliefs that such a situation could arise. But the laws of the Medes and Persians were in the main fair and just, and Jews no doubt readily obeyed them. Had it been otherwise they would not have enjoyed the favor that was often shown them. Through the prophet Jeremiah, God strictly enjoined them to be law-abiding, peaceful subjects wherever they might be (Jer. 29:7)."—SDA Bible Commentary, vol 3, p. 473.
Illustration: Although it is true that the Jewish people at the time of this story were recognized as law-abiding citizens, it equally is true that their forebears were not—at least not always. Thus, when the Jews first tried to rebuild the city of Jerusalem following the exile, the surrounding tribe wrote to the new Persian king reporting that: "You will discover by searching through the annals that this has been a rebellious city, harmful to the monarchy and its provinces, and that sedition has long been rife within its walls. That is why the city was laid waste. We submit to your majesty that, if it is rebuilt and its walls are completed, the result will be that you will have no more footing in the province Beyond-Euphrates" (Ezra 4:15, 16, NEB).
The king replied: "The letter you sent us has been read and translated in my presence. I issued an order and a search was made, and it was found that this city has a long history of revolt against kings and has been a place of rebellion and sedition" (Ezra 4:19, 20, NIV).
What strategy did Haman use in his approach to the king to gain approval for his plan? Esther 3:9.
One estimate suggests that Haman's offer equaled two-thirds of the annual income of the Persian empire. Involved in his struggles with the Greeks, Xerxes (Ahasuerus) must have found the bribe an overwhelming temptation. Also, the ease with which Haman swayed the king demonstrates the power of a favored courtier over an Oriental despot.
What did the king do after a date for the slaughter had been settled? Esther 3:10, 11.
The ancient Oriental rulers, as has been true of too many rulers throughout human history, surrounded themselves with courtiers and advisers who told them what they wanted to hear, or catered to their egos and vanities. Too often, as in the case of Xerxes, they were rewarded for their dangerous advice.
III. Decree Sent Out (Esther 3:12-15)
CONTRAST the mood of Haman and Ahasuerus with that of the Jews following the release of the edict (Esther 3:15-4:3). Do Haman's and Ahasuerus' reactions remind you of other leaders in history?
Search and Learn: What proclamations did other rulers of Persia issue?
Ezra 1:2-4
Ezra 6:1-12
Ezra 7:11-28
The Persian rulers were noted for their tolerance toward different cultures and religions. As a means to obtain the loyalty of the various peoples they conquered, they supplied funds to restore ruined temples and to support local religious services. Religious tolerance was a major policy of the Persian imperial government. Thus the incident portrayed in the book of Esther puzzles many because it seems so out of character. The Assyrians would order the destruction of an entire people—but the Persians? Some have rejected the historicity of Esther because of this fact.
But the Persian empire was quite capable of genocide. History preserves several other incidents similar to the fate threatened for the Jews. In 522 B.C. at the death of King Cambyses, Smerdes the Magus usurped the throne. But after only eight months of rule, he was slain by Darius, and in the resulting upheaval, the Persians in the capital massacred every member of the Magi—the high priestly class—that they could find.
Herodotus stated: "The anniversary of this day has been a red-letter day in the Persian calendar, marked by an important festival known as the Magophonia, or Killing of the Magi, during which no Magus is allowed to show himself—every member of the caste stays indoors till the day is over."—The Histories III, 79.
Xerxes himself had Babylon destroyed after the city rebelled against him. Persian rulers—like the Assyrians in previous centuries—also deported entire populations.
Think It Through: How can leaders and administrators protect themselves from being misguided by the counsel, views, or ambitions of others? What kind of people should a good leader choose as his or her helpers and advisers? What can leaders do to make sure that they understand all they can about a problem before making a decision?
Notes:
Further Study and Meditation: Read Ezekiel 18. In the same way that negative influences continue to spread, positive influences have a ripple effect that someday may astound us.
"Many a worker sends out into the world messages of strength and hope and courage, words that carry blessing to hearts in every land; but of the results he, toiling in loneliness and obscurity, knows little. So gifts are bestowed, burdens are borne, labor is done. Men sow the seeds from which, above their graves, others reap blessed harvests. They plant trees, that others may eat the fruit. They are content here to know that they have set in motion agencies for good. In the hereafter the action and reaction of all will be seen.
"Of every gift that God has bestowed, leading men to unselfish effort, a record is kept in heaven. To trace this in wide-spreading lines, to look upon those who by our efforts have been uplifted and ennobled, to behold in their history the outworking of true principles—this will be one of the studies and rewards of the heavenly school."—Education, p. 306.
Summary: A king who sought to conquer the world was himself conquered by a fawning and equally ambitious courtier, Haman. Sin destroys, but God saves.
Application
- Consider the individuals and nations mentioned in this lesson, comparing them to yourself and the people around you.
- What similarities do you see? What differences? What lessons can you learn from their experience?
- When it seems that you are surrounded with evil influences and that evil is triumphing, what can you do to gain a clear understanding of the fact that good eventually will gain the victory? What can you do to help others also gain this insight?
Bible texts in this lesson
Esther 3:1-15 · Galatians 6:7 · Esther 3:1-5 · Esther 3:1 · 1 Samuel 15:1-35 · Esther 3:2 · 1 Samuel 24:8 · 2 Samuel 14:4 · 1 Kings 1:16 · Esther 3:3 · Esther 3:4 · Esther 3:5 · Esther 3:6-11 · Esther 3:6 · Esther 3:7 · Joshua 7 · Esther 3:8-11 · Esther 3:8 · Jeremiah 29:7 · Ezra 4:15 · Ezra 4:16 · Ezra 4:19 · Ezra 4:20 · Esther 3:9 · Esther 3:10 · Esther 3:11 · Esther 3:12-15 · Ezra 1:2-4 · Ezra 6:1-12 · Ezra 7:11-28 · Ezekiel 18
My notes
Saved in this browser. Sign in to see your notes on other devices.