Lesson 5 · August 4, 1984
Forgiveness and Guilt
July 29 through August 4.
Memory Text: "I will arise and go to my father, and will say unto him, Father, I have sinned against heaven, and before thee, and am no more worthy to be called thy son: make me as one of thy hired servants" (Luke 15:18, 19).
One of the most common problems Christians have is separating what they believe in their minds from what they experience in their hearts. A person may spend years thinking about God's forgiveness, but never live free of guilt. In many cases, when a person finds it difficult to believe that God has forgiven him, this inability indicates that the person has not forgiven himself. In the parable of the prodigal son the father gave every evidence of forgiveness. But what if the son had insisted on being a servant in the father's house rather than being restored to sonship? What if he had felt so undeserving of his father's graciousness that he refused it? Would that not indicate that the son could not forgive himself?
Another way to look at it is to suggest that such a person believes it is appropriate for him or her to be punished in some way. He has been so bad that he should not be forgiven freely. As long as we are more comfortable being punished for what we do wrong than being forgiven, we will find it difficult to accept God's grace—difficult to forgive ourselves.
Guilt blown out of proportion becomes what can be called "neurotic guilt." Instead of dealing decisively and quickly with their guilt, neurotics grovel in it. True, all of us are guilty before God and stand alienated and hostile in relation to Him. But because guilt was designed to help us sense our need of His grace, once we do accept God's forgiveness, guilt should disappear. Guilt that persists after forgiveness can be either self-imposed or imposed on us by others. When as children we repeatedly hear the message that we are worthless, bad, or hopeless, we cannot help but believe it. The guilt that comes from such messages gets mixed in with the convicting work of the Holy Spirit later in life. As a result, when the Word of God tells us that we are forgiven and should be free of guilt, we feel just as condemned as ever. Jesus came for the purpose of freeing us from inordinate guilt and bringing peace, happiness, and assurance to those who are willing by His grace to put sin away.
Part 1 — Sunday, July 29
Mary Finally Forgave Herself
"When Jesus was risen early the first day of the week, he appeared first to Mary Magdalene, out of whom he had cast seven devils" (Mark 16:9)
Only God can forgive sins; but in order to accept His forgiveness, we need to forgive ourselves. Reading between the lines, Mary apparently felt that, as bad as she was, she could not be accepted and forgiven. But Jesus led her to accept full pardon and restoration.
"Mary had been looked upon as a great sinner, but Christ knew the circumstances that had shaped her life. He might have extinguished every spark of hope in her soul, but He did not. It was He who had lifted her from despair and ruin. Seven times she had heard His rebuke of the demons that controlled her heart and mind. She had heard His strong cries to the Father in her behalf. She knew how offensive is sin to His unsullied purity, and in His strength she had overcome.
"When to human eyes her case appeared hopeless, Christ saw in Mary capabilities for good. He saw the better traits of her character. The plan of redemption had invested humanity with great possibilities, and in Mary these possibilities were to be realized. Through His grace she became a partaker of the divine nature."—The Desire of Ages, p. 568.
Notice that, in spite of her despair, Mary kept returning to Christ for pardon. Are we as persistent?
Even though she had failed Him again, He inspired hope in her for pardon and a new acceptance. She began to see herself as Jesus saw her—someone pure, noble, and full of possibilities. This is what it means to "forgive oneself." To the extent we do not, we slow down the process of acceptance and victory. What we believe we are we tend to become. If we truly believe that we are forgiven sinners, we will live as forgiven people; as Mary did when, after much effort on Christ's part, she was freed from domination by the powers of evil.
Think It Through: List the names of three Bible characters who found it difficult to forgive themselves:
- 1.______
- 2.______
- 3.______
Notes
Further Study: Steps to Christ, "Faith and Acceptance," pp. 49-55.
Part 2 — Monday, July 30
"I Give Up"
"Will the Lord spurn for ever, and never again be favorable? Has his steadfast love for ever ceased? Are his promises at an end for all time? Has God forgotten to be gracious? Has he in anger shut up his compassion?" (Ps. 77:7-9, RSV).
Something seems to have kept the psalmist (at least at the moment of writing) from enjoying the benefits of a deep faith. When this happens, most of the time it is caused by guilt.
Christian counselors make a distinction between real guilt and emotional guilt. Real guilt is the result of an actual moral rebellion or mistake, rather than a nagging feeling, and it lasts only until the guilty person repents. Emotional guilt often has no genuine source in a person's life-style or behavior, and it persists far too long. Whenever guilt is not handled properly, we start playing "games" to deal with it, games such as these: (1) "I give up" (which leads to discouragement or depression); (2) rebellion against authority; (3) "I'm not bad after all"; or, (4) superficial confession and dishonesty about our need which leads to no change in our basic relationship with God and with others. The experience of alcoholics shows how the "I give up" game works. Such people—because of their broken promises, their ruined relationships, their shattered self-worth—suffer from profound guilt. Their lives repeat this pattern in a cyclical fashion, which makes them feel all the more guilty. Very often their response to this vicious set of circumstances is depression—combined with even heavier drinking—which sometimes leads to suicide.
Christ's solution to guilt avoids "games." Because He is God, when He speaks the word of forgiveness, of new beginnings, people receive a new motivation to challenge life. They cease rebelling against authority because they recognize that the highest authority in the universe is on their side, and they face their weakness honestly.
In the light of what we have just studied, what encouragement is found in 2 Corinthians 5:17?
Emotional problems are not necessarily spiritual ones. When we are battered by tragedies or suffering from physical disease or loneliness, we often experience depression. But this is not necessarily spiritual depression. Emotional depression does not last beyond the existence of the cause; or, in the case of grief over a loved one's death, it does not persist so long that it forever cripples our effectiveness to live whole lives again. For example, although she spoke strongly against unnatural depression (see Testimonies, vol. 4, p. 64), Ellen White tells us that her struggle with periods of depression did not destroy her faith. David knew depression as well. Even when occasions of spiritual depression do befall us as Christians, thank God there is hope. Review the experience of Peter.
Part 3 — Tuesday, July 31
Rebellion
"Fathers, do not provoke your children to anger, but bring them up in the discipline and instruction of the Lord" (Eph. 6:4, RSV).
Some people, plagued by guilt they have refused to face, are like boilers waiting to explode. Years of repressing their guilt have turned it into rage and rebellion. According to psychologists, our parents, by demanding too much, criticizing too much, affirming and praising too little, can produce harmful guilt in us. This process becomes even more acute in the context of religion.
The story of Cain illustrates this point. Notice that Cain (1) became angry and committed the murder of his brother, (2) experienced guilt as a result, and (3) dealt with his guilt by rebelling against God's authority that condemned him. (See Gen. 4:16).
Failure after failure while trying to be perfect without a close experience to Christ often produces an explosion of throwing all values away and leaving the church in an attempt to gain some peace of mind. High standards are essential, as long as the gospel is their center. But without the balance of love for Christ as the basis of high standards, church members can experience frustration that leads to rebellion.
What kind of emphasis will help Adventist parents, pastors, and teachers avoid imparting an unhealthful guilt to young people? 1 John 4:7-12.
Behavior is important to the extent that it affects our relationships with God and other people. Life-style standards, while important, must never be allowed to become more important than people. Often adults do not listen enough to young people. Listening to and building better relationships with the youth often leads them to decide to straighten out their actions. Gently and kindly parents are to lead their children in the path of obedience, recognizing that doing so will ensure true happiness. "A sacred duty rests upon parents to guide their children into paths of strict obedience. True happiness in this life and in the future life depends upon obedience to a 'Thus saith the Lord.' Parents, let Christ's life be the pattern."—Child Guidance, p. 80.
What does Ephesians 6:4 mean when it admonishes parents to bring up their children "in the discipline and instruction of the Lord"?
"Strict discipline may at times cause dissatisfaction, and children will want their own way; yet where they have learned the lesson of obedience to their parents, they are better prepared to submit to the requirements of God. Thus the training received in childhood influences the religious experience and molds the character of the man."—Child Guidance, p. 85.
Part 4 — Wednesday, August 1
"I'm Not Bad After All"
"When Ahab saw Elijah, Ahab said to him, 'Is it you, you troubler of Israel?' And he answered, 'I have not troubled Israel; but you have, and your father's house, because you have forsaken the commandments of the Lord and followed the Baals' " (1 Kings 18:17, 18, RSV).
Another destructive way to deal with guilt is to trivialize it by convincing ourselves that we really are not guilty. We sometimes call this "rationalizing." It may take the following forms:
- Compared to what others have done, this act is nothing; or, compared to other people, I am a saint.
- My actions are not really wrong. It is morality that is wrong.
- It is not my fault. Others are to blame.
This last reaction characterized Adam and Eve after they had sinned. Adam blamed God for giving him Eve and Eve blamed the serpent. Our introductory text tells us that Ahab blamed Elijah for his problems, and in 1 Samuel 15 we learn that Saul blamed the people for his disobedience. Shifting the blame is a universal practice. It is painful to admit that we broke a promise or lied—so painful that we will do almost anything to avoid confronting our mistake. Adam and Eve, having no other humans to blame, attempted to excuse their actions by blaming the serpent, and, indirectly, God. Some people who indulge their sexual appetites in violation of the law blame God for creating them that way.
How varied are the excuses we are prone to make? Luke 14:18-20.
When we make excuses, most of the time we blame other people such as our parents or our spouses or our economic situation. There are occasions when the way in which we were raised and our financial difficulties are factors, but we can never (at least almost never) hold other people or conditions ultimately responsible for what we decide to do. That is a denial of our dignity and freedom as self-determining creatures. Perhaps this is why Ellen White constantly reminds us that we underestimate the power of the will.
Think It Through: List three people in Scripture besides those already mentioned who tried to ignore their guilt by blaming others.
- ______
- ______
- ______
Further Study: Patriarchs and Prophet, pp. 52-62.
Part 5 — Thursday, August 2
Superficial Confession
"I have sinned this time; the Lord is the righteous one, and I and my people are the wicked ones. Make supplication to the Lord, for there has been enough of God's thunder and hail; and I will let you go, and you shall stay no longer" (Ex. 9:27 28, NASB).
This text is quoted in Freedom From Guilt, by Narramore and Counts, to illustrate what they call the most clever and deceptive guilt "game" of all, played to perfection by Pharaoh in relation to Moses.
"When we feel guilty, we feel miserable: we like ourselves less, feel a sense of alienation from God, and fear his punishment or retribution. The guilt becomes so painful that we admit we're wrong to get relief, ask forgiveness, and wait for the pain to go away. Often this confession works like a magic wand—in no time at all the guilt seems to vanish and we feel good about ourselves, accepted by God and free from punishment.
"But what was the motive for confession? Were we concerned about the person we hurt? Were we sorry about doing wrong? Or were we just trying to rid ourselves of unpleasant guilt feelings? I think we will have to admit that much of our confession is done more to relieve the pangs of guilt than to alter our behavior for the good of others. Don't we often ask God's forgiveness when we know we will do the same thing again? And aren't our prayers for forgiveness often just a routine, conscience-clearing endeavor?"—Bruce Narramore and Bill Counts, Freedom From Guilt (Santa Ana, Calif.: Vision House Publishers, 1974), p. 32.
How can we know that we truly have repented? 2 Chron. 7:14; Isa. 55:7.
"Repentance includes sorrow for sin and a turning away from it."—Steps to Christ, p. 23. These well-known words contain profound depths. To the extent that sin causes suffering (and it always does), true repentance always senses how much others and God suffer because of our sins and turns away from them for that reason. Confession and forgiveness which is focused only on relieving our own suffering will not lead to victory over sin.
"The exceeding sinfulness [of sin] can be estimated only in the light of the cross."—Steps to Christ, p. 31. Those Christians most conscious of how sin causes the suffering Jesus endured on the cross are the ones who learn to hate it with intense passion and turn away from it in disgust. Once this happens, we no longer play "guilt games"; instead, we face honestly the greed and lust and pride within ourselves and confess it. Once faith in God's eternal forgiveness has been exercised by us, we can truly believe that, because of Jesus' death on the cross, it is no longer appropriate for us to feel guilty over sins we have placed on Him.
Part 6 — Friday, August 3
Focus of the Week
"He that covereth his sins shall not prosper: but whoso confesseth and forsaketh them shall have mercy" (Prov. 28:13).
When we make excuses for our sins we give evidence that we still cherish them. On the other hand, it is not enough to confess sincerely. Genuine confession must be accompanied by the desire to forsake sins, an attempt to make amends whenever possible, and by successful resistance of temptation through the strength and power that God promises. (See Phil. 2:13; 1 John 3:6-8.) If God were to forgive and bless those who cling to sin, He would perpetuate all the evil that sin has brought.
Personal Applications: This week we have studied "games" people play that enable them to deal with guilt other than God's way. Check the "games" list below to see if you can identify which "games" you have used recently to avoid confessing and forsaking sin.
- "I give up" (and give in to depression and neurotic guilt).
- Rebellion against authority (throwing standards and values away).
- "I'm not so bad after all" (shifting the blame to someone else).
- 4.Superficial confession ("I said I'm sorry, so forget it").
Notes
Think It Through: Study the following quotation; then summarize the quoted material in one comprehensive sentence that you can share with those who need it:
"Confess your sins to God, who only can forgive them, and your faults to one another. . . .
"Those who have not humbled their souls before God in acknowledging their guilt have not yet fulfilled the first condition of acceptance. If we have not experienced that repentance which is not to be repented of, and have not with true humiliation of soul and brokenness of spirit confessed our sins, abhorring our iniquity, we have never truly sought for the forgiveness of sin; and if we have never sought, we have never found the peace of God. . . . Confession of sin, whether public or private, should be heartfelt and freely expressed. It is not to be urged from the sinner. . . .
"True confession is always of a specific character, and acknowledges particular sins. They may be of such a nature as to be brought before God only; they may be wrongs that should be confessed to individuals who have suffered injury through them; or they may be of a public character, and should then be as publicly confessed. But all confession should be definite and to the point, acknowledging the very sins of which you are guilty."—Steps to Christ, pp. 37, 38.
Summarize: ______
Bible texts in this lesson
Luke 15:18 · Luke 15:19 · Mark 16:9 · Psalms 77:7-9 · 2 Corinthians 5:17 · Ephesians 6:4 · Genesis 4:16 · 1 John 4:7-12 · 1 Kings 18:17 · 1 Kings 18:18 · 1 Samuel 15 · Luke 14:18-20 · Exodus 9:27 · 2 Chronicles 7:14 · Isaiah 55:7 · Proverbs 28:13 · Philippians 2:13 · 1 John 3:6-8
My notes
Saved in this browser. Sign in to see your notes on other devices.