Skip to content

Lesson 4 · July 26, 1975

Credentials for Church Leadership

"And without controversy great is the mystery of godliness: God was manifest in the flesh, justified in the Spirit, seen of angels, preached unto the Gentiles, believed on in the world, received up into glory." 1 Tim. 3:16.

Among Paul's concerns as he wrote to Timothy was efficient leadership in the young Christian communities. In other letters that Paul had written (Rom. 12:1-8, e.g.), he had made clear that the spirit and principles of Christian leadership are vastly different from those that govern the leaders of secular institutions. For the Christian, leadership is not a matter of status but of service. How different from the relations that prevail between leaders and followers in the army or in a great corporation!

Within a century and a half after Paul's death a terrible misunderstanding regarding the authority of ecclesiastical office had been established. Because of this tragedy millions were destined to suffer and die in the centuries that followed. As a result, authentic Christianity nearly vanished from the earth.

Paul's specifications for the selection of leaders, as set forth in this week's lesson, stress the leader's personal example and positive spiritual image. Executive ability alone does not qualify a man to be a responsible Christian leader. Knowing human nature as he did, Paul foresaw the danger that love of position and power would lead men to conclude—consciously or unconsciously—that office makes a man holy and right, that it guarantees correct belief.

Another unfortunate misconception is that one church office is inherently superior to another, and that it confers greater holiness to the one who holds the higher offices.

In Paul's instruction to Timothy he stresses the New Testament principle of faith-fellowship, not the traditional misconception of dogma-institution. The church is not a building, nor an institution, but a fellowship of men of faith who reveal the truth about life. They demonstrate the superiority and winsomeness of the God-directed life, and they are reliving before the world God's message in Jesus—that truth is not merely a matter of knowing the will of God, but of doing it.

Only Christlike leaders of the Christian community can rightly represent the One who said, "I am . . . the truth." Only irreproachable believers of integrity can be pillars and bulwarks of the truth. The gates of hell, Christ said, would never be able to prevail against that kind of church.

Lesson Outline

  1. 1.The Household of God, 1 Tim. 3:14, 15
  2. 2.The Mystery of Our Religion, 1 Tim. 3:16
  3. 3.The Elder—1, 1 Tim. 3:2, 3
  4. 4.The Elder—2, 1 Tim. 3:4, 5
  5. 5.The Deacon—1, 1 Tim. 3:8-10
  6. 6.The Deacon—2, 1 Tim. 3:12, 13

Part 1 — Sunday, July 20

The Household of God

What was Paul's chief reason for writing to Timothy?

"I hope to come to you soon, but I am writing these instructions to you so that, if I am delayed, you may know how one ought to behave in the household of God, which is the church of the living God, the pillar and bulwark of the truth." 1 Tim. 3:14, 15, RSV.

Here Paul gives his reason for writing not only the specific instructions regarding elders and deacons but also the general summary of his important teachings that we now call 1 Timothy.

Paul planned to visit Timothy in Ephesus soon. But knowing the uncertainty of travel and other hazards, Paul wanted to be certain that Timothy had in his hands authoritative guidelines for the organization of the Ephesians into a model church for Asia Minor. Every church since has had the privilege of checking its own procedures against the inspired instruction given by Paul.

The church is not a human institution even though it must be humanly administered. This fact has been hard to remember for many innovators throughout the history of the church. Even though the church is a living fellowship, organized by and for the general welfare of its members, it is also the "pillar and bulwark of the truth."

What relationship exists between the behavior of Christians and the fact that they are to function as the "pillar and bulwark of the truth"? Verse 15.

Worshiping and representing a living God requires a living dynamic faith that is easily distinguished from the anxious, self-indulging men and women living without Christ. The Christian church has more assigned to it than merely to proclaim information—even if that information were without error. To be the "bulwark" or the buttress of the truth means that truth is believable only when the lives of the professing church members back up and clearly give visible structure to the word that is preached.

The central truth of the gospel is that God is able (Jude 24) to keep Christians from sin. Paul proclaims that "we are more than conquerors through him that loved us." Rom. 8:37.

Only when Christians reveal this power and manifest God's purposes will God be rightly represented and vindicated.

Think It Through: What relationship is there between a clear, living witness to the truth about the living God and the end of the world?

Further Study: Christ's Object Lessons, "First the Blade, Then the Ear," pages 62-69.

Part 2 — Monday, July 21

The Mystery of Our Religion

What is the great mystery of the universe that could be made known only through revelation?

"Great indeed, we confess, is the mystery of our religion:
He was manifested in the flesh,
vindicated in the Spirit, seen by angels,
preached among the nations,
believed on in the world, taken up in glory." 1 Tim. 3:16, RSV.

Why does Paul call Christianity a mystery?

In the New Testament frequent references are made to the mysteries of certain aspects of the gospel and to the gospel generally. See Rom. 16:25; 1 Cor. 2:7; Eph. 3:3, 4. But mystery is not used here to suggest that something is covered up and kept secret. Although Paul uses "mystery" often, he always refers to divinely revealed truth that God wants all men to know. It is a mystery in the sense that it could be known in no other way than by God's revelation.

How else, except through revelation, could anyone understand the incarnation of Jesus or His resurrection?

The greatness that Paul stresses is not the mysterious nature of the gospel but its importance, its earthshaking possibilities. Any genuine Christian reading Paul's letter would quickly say Amen!

Think It Through:

Would you confess with Paul that the central fact and inspiration of your personal understanding of the gospel is the incarnation of Jesus? How would you answer the question: What is the great uniqueness of the Christian religion?

In verse 9 Paul emphasizes that church officers must possess "the mystery of faith with a clear conscience." In verse 16 he discloses the grounds for faith, the substance that faith believes, "the mystery of our religion."

Six tremendous facts (verse 16) about Jesus, God who became man, provide the reason Christians have hope for the future, an endless resource to love in spite of provocation, and a life-style that reverses the degeneration of the human race.

That God became man is the most stimulating, most refreshing, most thoroughly unique statement ever uttered by man. The tragedy is that the Christian church has been most responsible over the years for diluting the meaning of the incarnation by not recognizing that He became truly man. By fearing to suggest that the Holy God should know the tug of temptation, they have minimized His actual feat of being the first man to live without sin.

Further Study: Selected Messages, Bk. 1, pp. 252-256.

Part 3 — Tuesday, July 22

The Elder—1

What high standards were to guide the church in the selection of its leaders?

"A bishop then must be blameless, the husband of one wife, vigilant, sober, of good behaviour, given to hospitality, apt to teach; not given to wine, no striker, not greedy of filthy lucre; but patient, not a brawler, not covetous." 1 Tim. 3:2, 3.

The word "bishop" is the translation for the Greek word that literally means "overseer"; in the New Testament this word and another translated "elder" are used interchangeably, one referring to the scope of his work and the other to the dignity that befits such a leader.

The emphasis on the leader's irreproachable character as known among people outside the church as well as by fellow Christians is placed in proper perspective. The word "must" is strongly emphasized in the Greek as it should be. By the very nature of the case, Christian leaders must be living illustrations of the truth they profess to teach, not only for the sake of the community in general but also as a model for fellow members.

Also interesting in Paul's requirements of the elder is that there is nothing about this list, except perhaps "apt to teach," that is any different from that expected of all church members. Paul does not recognize two spiritual divisions within the church: first-class being the clergy, and second-class, the laity.

"Husband of one wife" means that the church leader must be a man who is irreproachable in the area of sexual conduct. Although marital fidelity was taken very lightly in Paul's day, this instruction has never grown out-of-date. Perhaps it is needed to be said today as much as Paul needed to say it then.

"Vigilant" means literally, "an abstainer from wine." The elder should refrain from all that is harmful and use all else judiciously.

"Sober" suggests prudence; every church needs sound-minded leaders who can detect imbalance and fanaticism on one hand and devious liberalism on the other.

"Good behaviour" calls for leaders who are true Christian gentlemen. They exhibit a fitness and propriety that, sum up the previously mentioned traits.

"Apt to teach" does not mean merely that the elder should be willing to teach but that he be able to teach with a certain measure of skill.

Think It Through: Paul lists five negatives that must not be a part of the leader's reputation or character. Is there often a correlation between some or all five of these negative characteristics?

Part 4 — Wednesday, July 23

The Elder—2

How closely do a leader's children affect his church work?

"He must manage his own household well, keeping his children submissive and respectful in every way; for if a man does not know how to manage his own household, how can he care for God's church?" 1 Tim. 3:4, 5, RSV.

For two reasons ill-mannered children are a liability to a church leader, whether he be a minister or local elder; they are a poor exhibit of the power of Christianity, and they give evidence that the father is incompetent for church leadership. Paul is using the argument of the less to the greater—if a man fails in a smaller task (that of managing his own family), he is incapable of successfully managing the many families that compose a local congregation.

Although a man may possess all the other qualities that Paul lists, a recent convert or a hopeful beginner should not be elevated to important church responsibilities. Age is not Paul's point; spiritual maturity is.

What are some of the dangers that may overtake a man who has been prematurely placed in a position of heavy responsibility? Verse 6.

Paul mentions how subtle conceit may be, even in a man of good intentions. Pride loses perspective; the affected one makes hasty decisions, not realizing the implications of the problem. The ability to listen to others is not a mark of a proud man or of many inexperienced men. Falling into the same condemnation that Satan has received may sound harsh, but Paul was realistic.

In determining the qualifications of church leaders, how high a premium should be placed on the opinion of persons outside the church? Verse 7.

Again Paul uses the strong emphasis in the Greek: "He must be well thought of by outsiders." RSV. The potential church leader should enjoy a favorable reputation. Apparently, he should be someone who is already recognized as a man of integrity in his community.

Think It Through: Have you ever heard that a member was put into leadership in order to encourage him, showing that the church was interested in him? Why might this be a disaster for that person?

Further Study: The Desire of Ages, pages 249-251.

Part 5 — Thursday, July 24

The Deacon—1

How does Paul describe the qualities expected of a deacon?

"Deacons likewise must be serious, not double-tongued, not addicted to much wine, not greedy for gain; they must hold the mystery of the faith with a clear conscience. And let them also be tested first; then if they prove themselves blameless let them serve as deacons." 1 Tim. 3:8-10, RSV.

The precise nature of the deacon's responsibility is not made clear in the New Testament, and about all we know is found in the above text and Philippians 1:1. In Rom. 16:1 reference is made to a woman called a deaconess. (See RSV.) Although the seven men, including Stephen, who were appointed to aid widows in the Jerusalem church (Acts 6) were not called deacons, it seems that their great assistance in relieving the apostles for preaching caused early leaders like Paul to think seriously about such a group in every church.

About the only difference between the qualifications for the deacon and the elder is that the deacons are not expected to be especially trained as official teachers of the church. Paul expected the same spiritual and moral standards to be upheld by both levels of leadership.

Being double-tongued is a serious problem for anyone, but it is a grave problem indeed for someone who has the responsibility of making the rounds of visitation as expected of a deacon or an elder. They would hear much that would require careful discernment; instead of a peacemaker, a double-tongued leader would be a troublemaker.

The warning against greed does not indicate that moneymaking is evil. It is a warning against dishonorable gain such as tripped up Judas as he handled the disciples' funds. The deacon in his personal business should plan to be successful, but it should be earned honestly. Certainly the deacon should not use his office for personal gain, even though he might not do anything legally dishonest.

Think It Through:

Why does Paul again join faith and conscience? Is it because Paul demands more than "a good conscience"? Can a person have a good conscience and do some very bad acts?

Every potential candidate for church office should ask himself whether his conscience can approve his life-style when compared with the expectations of God's will.

As for the elder, so with the deacon—no one should be hurried into church office. There must be a record of mature Christian living. Church offices were not made so that the careless may be given a chance to prove themselves.

Further Study: The Desire of Ages, pages 437-439.

Part 6 — Friday, July 25

The Deacon—2

What are the legitimate rewards for those who serve well in church office?

"Let deacons be married only once, and let them manage their children and their households well; for those who serve well as deacons gain a good standing for themselves and also great confidence in the faith which is in Christ Jesus." 1 Tim. 3:12, 13, RSV.

Again, as with the elders (verse 2), Paul places a high premium on a deacon's marital fidelity and his ability to manage his own household. All Christians should be faithful to their marital vows; if there is reason to question, that person should never be appointed a deacon or an elder.

Apparently Paul feels that ill-tempered, disobedient children are sufficient evidence that a man, in spite of other executive abilities, is disqualified to assume the function of a church leader.

Think It Through:

What satisfactions and compensations await a church officer who performs his duties conscientiously?

Certainly men and women who do their church duties faithfully will enjoy the respect and confidence of their fellow church members. More than that, their commitment will be noticed by people outside the church and could become an avenue of blessing to such.

More than the well-deserved commendation and respect of others is the church worker's growing confidence in his Lord's guidance. He knows that without the assurance of his Lord's care and power many would be the occasions for 'defeat and discouragement. Nothing prepares a man for larger tasks more than the settled confidence that God is always able to provide the wisdom and strength needed, regardless of the duty assigned. Developing such boldness of faith is the highest form of compensation that any Christian could hope for.

"The humble worker who obediently responds to the call of God may be sure of receiving divine assistance. To accept so great and holy a responsibility is itself elevating to the character. It calls into action the highest mental and spiritual powers, and strengthens and purifies the mind and heart. Through faith in the power of God, it is wonderful how strong a weak man may become, how decided his efforts, how prolific of great results. . . . The more one tries to explain the word of God to others, with a love for souls, the plainer it becomes to himself. The more we use our knowledge and exercise our powers, the more knowledge and power we shall have."—Christ's Object Lessons, page 354.

Further Study: Christ's Object Lessons, "Talents," pages 360-365.

Bible texts in this lesson

1 Timothy 3:16 · Romans 12:1-8 · 1 Timothy 3:14 · 1 Timothy 3:15 · 1 Timothy 3:2 · 1 Timothy 3:3 · 1 Timothy 3:4 · 1 Timothy 3:5 · 1 Timothy 3:8-10 · 1 Timothy 3:12 · 1 Timothy 3:13 · Jude 1:24 · Romans 8:37 · Romans 16:25 · 1 Corinthians 2:7 · Ephesians 3:3 · Ephesians 3:4 · Ephesians 3:9 · Ephesians 3:16 · 1 Timothy 3:6 · 1 Timothy 3:7 · Philippians 1:1 · Romans 16:1 · Acts 6

My notes

Saved in this browser. Sign in to see your notes on other devices.

Download lesson PDF Download quarter PDF · 13 lessons